They Call Me Mista Yu
← All episodes

They Call Me Mista Yu - The Socialist Struggle

33:37

Have a question or thought for Mista Yu? Text or leave a voicemail for the show and he’ll answer it personally on the Inspiration Station or They Call Me Mista Yu. With your Permission, We'll even play your message live on the air!

You hear “socialism” and “fascism” thrown around like everyone agrees on the definitions, but most of us are arguing past each other. We sit down with economic policy expert and author Doug Cardell to get painfully clear on terms people use every day and rarely define. Doug explains socialism as government ownership of the means of production and property, why Nordic countries are better described as capitalist social democracies, and why communism is more myth than lived reality.

From there we dig into the real fear: drifting into a controlled economy by accident because the slogans sound compassionate while the incentives stay hidden. Doug lays out two big failure points. First, human nature: systems that assume saintly behavior break fast. Second, the economics: planning requires prediction, and prediction is weak. He shares a striking example of forecasts landing around coin-flip accuracy, then connects it to a simple truth about a global economy: nobody can reliably “read the minds” of billions of buyers.

We also talk about why definitions are getting muddier, what to do when dictionaries and the internet disagree, and how to build your own media literacy without becoming cynical. The conversation ends on a sharper, more hopeful idea of capitalism: stop obsessing over “working for a living” and start thinking about creating value for other people. Along the way we touch income inequality, per capita GDP, the decline in extreme poverty, and why innovators like Bezos, Gates, and Musk are better understood through the value they create than the wealth they hold.

Subscribe for more conversations like this, share the episode with a friend who loves policy debates, and leave a review with your biggest takeaway.

Support the show

In this episode

Read the transcript
SPEAKER_01: Welcome back today, Call of Mr. You, the flagship show that started it all. I'm your host, Mr. Yu. So glad you guys are here with us. If you're watching for the very, very first time, I don't know how that's possible, but if you are a new listener, a new viewer, thanks for making us part of your week. We're live on LinkedIn, YouTube, and Facebook right now as we speak. If you have a question for myself or a guest, by all means, drop it in the comment section. We'll do our best to answer those right here live on the air. So thanks again for making us part of your week. Tune in, lock in with us. It's gonna be a fun episode. Today we're gonna have a special guest, economic policy expert Doug Cardell's in the house. Bring him on stage right now. Doug, how are you, sir? Great, how are you? Fantastic. Good to have you here, man. Most people that watch our show have been following us for about six years now. So they kind of know that this is the only show out of our four shows where I'm liable to talk about anything under the sun. It just wasn't whatever's in the wild mind of Mr. U. So today we're gonna have a big departure from what I normally talk about, but I'm leaning on your expertise and on your wisdom, man, to kind of help guide us through this incredible topic, man. But before we get into what you do and what you're best known for, kind of give us a brief overview of where you're from, how you got from that place as a young dub to who you are today, man. Go ahead. SPEAKER_00: Oh well, it's been a long and complicated journey. I probably don't have time to do much but hit the highlights, but do the best we can. My first job, I had a bunch of jobs while I was in college and early before that, but then I my next job was as a aide to a congressman, and then I became a YMCA director, owned an advertising agency, went into education, taught junior high, high school, college, university, and now I'm a writer. SPEAKER_01: Wow. That sounds like a long, a long journey. It's like a lot of experience uh embedded in that too. So I'm excited to get into some of this stuff, man. One of the things that I noticed when I was uh kind of checking you out a little bit, I think we can agree that there's a few topics that uh we don't hear about that are most out front today on the 24-hour news cycle, than government and economy. We're hearing about those probably more than anything. Uh, you did mention mention some areas with a certain terms that we hear a lot about that nobody knows what they mean, and we kind of just rally around what we think we know, the little that we know regarding capitalism, fascism, and socialism, and all the other isms. But if we want to make sure we have an understanding, so you're gonna be helping out all of our listeners and viewers, including myself, kind of understanding what is really going on around us from what you've been experiencing from our experience and research and what some of these terms actually mean. If I understand you write a book recently, why the struggles? SPEAKER_00: Why social struggles, yes. SPEAKER_01: What was first off, what is socialism in your in your estimation, and then tell us why you think it's struggles. Go ahead. SPEAKER_00: Yeah, uh well, I guess the first thing would be a like a formal definition. Socialism is a is a an economic system in which the government owns all the means of production and all property. That's something that most people don't understand. They think of socialism, a lot of people think of the Nordic countries, for example, like Sweden, Denmark. They are not socialists, they they call themselves social democracies, and so I think that's a lot of where the confusion comes from. They are capitalist countries that have a slightly larger safety net than the U.S. unknown: does. SPEAKER_00: The differences are actually pretty slight. Many of them are actually have freer economies than the U.S. does, that is less regulated economies than the U.S. does. And then socialism has two close cousins: communism. And communism is a myth. Marx's idea of communism was that socialism would become so successful that the government would wither away, was his phrase. Obviously, that's never happened, and I can't imagine that it's ever gonna happen because when people get in power, they don't give it up easily. And then fascism, a lot of people somehow believe fascism is the opposite of socialism. It's they're again very close cousins. In fascism, the government controls the means of production and all property, it doesn't own it outright, but it controls it. And so a good example of that would be Hitler's Germany. Well, they didn't outright take over things, but for example, Volkswagen was Hitler dictating to Porsche to build what he called the people's car. That's what Volkswagen means in German. And so fascism is when the government controls all the means of production, and I think I mean part of why I wrote the book, and part of why I'm worried, is that I think we could end up in in a fascist or a socialist state accidentally, because people vote for things that they don't understand, and by the time they figure it out, it could be too late. SPEAKER_01: That's very scary. Well, what what what's the what's the impetus behind uh it's kind of obvious to me, but for the sake of those that are watching and listening today, why are you so worried about that? What do you see in recent times that make you think, you know what, this could be a real concern? Why are you concerned about what you just got finished here? SPEAKER_00: Well, obviously, uh election recent elections in New York and Seattle, where we've elected socialist mayors, and Mandami, at least, is a true socialist. He's talking about taking over means of production, like instituting government grocery stores and things like that, that will do incredible harm. It's it's it's gonna destroy New York City if he gets his way. Now, the good news is he probably won't get to do most of the things he thinks he wants to do. He he doesn't, I don't think, understand the political realities as well as he probably should if he's gonna be the mayor of New York. Because he's gonna have to deal with a city council and a state government and a federal government that are all gonna be skeptical at the least of what he's trying to do. SPEAKER_01: Makes sense. I got a family in New York, that's my hometown, so I'm very, I guess, close to what's going on, and I try to stay with current events and just kind of just make sure that if my mom doesn't know what's happening in my family, I'm able to try to point them in what's in what's in what's happening in the right direction to get as much information as possible because there's a lot of rhetoric out there. We can clearly see that part, but definitely want to have uh some information. So when you wrote why socialism struggles, I mean you could have wrote about any of the things that you that you spoke so eloquently on just now, but why did you decide that that's the topic that needed to be first and foremost right now? Why why was that? SPEAKER_00: Well, socialism and and fascism are fairly unique compared to capitalism in that they they have failure built in. Um they there's the they struggle is a phrase I use, but because they can't work. They they fail on several grounds. First of all, in fact, the first time I became aware of that this whole idea, I was probably I don't know, 12. I don't remember who it was now. It may have been a teacher, I don't know. Oh, it was a woman trying to tell me the virtues of communism. SPEAKER_01: And I listened to her how did that go over? How she pushed that one as uh as something that you might want to do because it's so cool. SPEAKER_00: Yeah, she she was telling me how wonderful it was and how everybody would be equal. And and I said, Well, that won't work. She said, What do you mean that won't work? I said, Well, you're assuming that people are saints, that that they're willing to submit their own desires to somebody else. And I said, People don't do that. I in fact, I think I even said at the time, nothing living does that. Part of life is you gotta look out for yourself a little bit, and and every organism I've since learned that that I was basically right, even at 12, that every organism has to has to base its life on self-interest, not selfishness, but self-interest. You you gotta look out for yourself to an extent, and so I would suggest that that socialism doesn't work for that reason, but but more importantly, as I after getting a doctorate in economics, I did research and found out that it can't work economically either. And there's a really good reason for that. In order to plan an economy, and remember, in socialism, the government owns the means of production. That means there are no private companies, the companies are owned by the government, there's no private property, all that's owned by the government. Well, in order to plan those economies, they have to be able to predict what's gonna happen next. And part of my research was to look at a 30-year history of the Federal Reserve's projections of the consumer production expense the personal consumption expenditures, which is a really good measure of what people are gonna buy next. And so I looked at what the Fed predicted, looked a year later at what actually happened, they were right 46% of the time. You literally could have done better flipping a coin. And obviously, if you can't predict what's gonna happen, you can't plan what to do, and so and and to put it in you know somewhat more obvious terms for our listeners, there are nine billion people in the economy, in the world economy right now, and we we have a global economy. In order for me to plan how many cell phones to buy next year, build next year, how many cars to build next year, what kind of cars to build next year, I'd have to be able to read the minds of those nine billion people. I don't know what my wife is planning to buy next week. How the heck am I going to know what everybody in the world is planning to buy next year? It's nuts. It can't possibly happen. And it's because the economy is a chaotic system, it's like the weather. And I would challenge your listeners, get on your favorite weather app, look where the weather is supposed to be two weeks from now, write it down and see what happens. And it's gonna be wrong. I mean, some of sometimes it's gonna be close, but most of the time it's gonna be wrong. SPEAKER_01: I haven't tried that before I had almanac. I tried that to see if I can mainly to dispute weather uh forecasters and the weather personality to see it. Do they actually know what they're talking about? So I will go any almanac, pick a date, like you said, and see if it actually happens. And you know what? SPEAKER_00: Never seen it happen. Yeah, it doesn't work. In fact, last night our power was out for nine hours, supposed to be a calm sunny day, and they said there was a storm, it took our power out. So obviously the weather forecast was wrong. There was a storm instead of clear sunny days, and so yeah, yeah, you can't you can't plan what you can't predict. SPEAKER_01: I I think the thing that concerns me about things like socialism, because I I think I have a pretty good understanding of what it's about, which is why I feel the way I do about it. But I looked at up of this word in preparation for our talk today, just to get myself clear on that. I was at three different dictionaries. I won't name what they are because I might put them in a dispensing light, but I looked at three different dictionaries. And do you know they all have different definitions for that one word? Growing up, I'm a I'm a I'm a self-professed and and not recovering bookworm. I was a reader since I was a little kid. And I used to read Encyclopedia, Encyclopedia Britannica, read them fully all the way through. World book encyclopedia, dictionaries, thesauruses. I was a nerd to my heart and I and I own it and I'm happy about it. And I read, I read like that. I've never seen one word that had this many definitions. One definition says the government will control goods and resources and how they'd be allotted. The second dictionary said the community, which is very vague. Who's that? The community would have gonna decide how goods are distributed and to whom and how much to each. And the third one says corporations and private individuals would do that. How do we have three different definitions for one word? SPEAKER_00: Yeah, well, certainly part of it is a lot of what you could call media, including encyclopedias, encyclopedias, dictionaries, and so on, have been co-opted by people that have an agenda. And that's a real problem. We have gotten to the point where I don't think young people could do what you and I did in terms of reading and and gaining a lot of insight. Because I can try it. Yeah, the the difficulty for young people today is going to be they they are gonna have no idea what to believe. That's fair. Back when you and I were reading, and I too was a was a big reader and a nerd, and and and back then, most media by and large told the truth. And so you could pick up something, read it, and go, yeah, okay, I get that. But I I I feel really bad for young people today because they can't do that. And on places like the internet, it's far worse. You you probably could find a hundred definitions of socialism on the internet, not just three. What would you do, Dr. SPEAKER_01: Doug, if you had somebody who is a young person who cares about education? They care about understanding things and comprehending things. They also want to educate themselves and be independent thinkers. And he came to you to ask you to help them to understand what's true and what's not in what we hear around us. Are you able to help them? Do you turn them away sadly? Can you help them? What would you suggest? SPEAKER_00: Well, I think the the first thing is to look at a lot of sources, never believe the first thing you read, and then and then start with common sense. Say, does this ring true? Does it seem like something that's plausible, or does it seem like something that's just a little bit on the wacko side? And and a lot of it is. I mean, it's just crazy. I'm also a musician and I'm a big Beatles fan, but but John Lennon wasn't an economist, and so he wrote a song about communism, explaining, you know, you imagine there's no countries, no heaven, no no nothing, no possessions. And I and but he titled it correctly, it's in his imagination because he's he's imagining a world that could never really exist. I mean, how would no possessions work? I mean, that means we've got to share a toothbrush. I mean, yeah, you gotta share the tooth decay as well. SPEAKER_01: That's crazy. He's cool to a musician, man. So what kind of music do you play? Uh, mostly 50s and 60s is rock and roll, some blues. SPEAKER_00: Are you gonna band, Dr. Doug? Yeah, you bet. Wow, what's the name of the band? The Cardells. My wife and I are there. SPEAKER_01: So you play the instrument and your wife is uh singing lead. Is that how it's going? SPEAKER_00: Uh we both play instruments and we and we both play leads and we both sing leads. SPEAKER_01: That's awesome. And are the are the are the kids involved as well? Occasionally, yeah. I love it. You guys do gigs with them? Are you doing leads? SPEAKER_00: Are you getting gigs at it? You betcha, yeah. That's impressive. Is it like maybe two or three, maybe two or three a month? SPEAKER_01: Okay, and how long has this been going on, man? This is this is this is super this is super cool, man. Oh, 40 years. Wow, wow. What have you guys learned about this? I mean, because I know music has changed a lot and still has to some degree the songwriting process now. You got AI to help you do stuff, and and gigs might even be different now because of, you know, well, for a lot of obvious reasons that we already talked about. What's what's different for you guys at this stage of your your musical career, musical journey that it wasn't like back when you started? SPEAKER_00: Oh wow, that's a good question. Is it more fun? Are you bringing it to the I don't uh no no answers leap to mind? SPEAKER_01: Are you is is it is it more fun now? Are you are you uh feeling more freak freer, or do you feel more more restricted because of you know culture and and outside influences? How are we? SPEAKER_00: Yeah, there's more competition now, I guess. And more different kinds of music, but I mean, since we've stuck with the genres we're in, mostly rock and roll and blues, we the the we don't really compete with the same markets that some of the others do. So we you know we aren't competing with 80s pop or or 90s stuff or whatever. The people that like what we do like what we do. SPEAKER_01: That makes sense. So you just got to do it for a long time, you said 40 plus years. So is the goal still the same or has it changed over the decades? SPEAKER_00: Oh, we're we're mostly just trying to have fun. I mean, we just both love playing and we both love entertaining, and and I guess I mean it's like that line in blanking on this name right now, but from American Pie. I knew if I had my chance, I could make those people dance, and maybe they'd be happy for a while. That's kind of what it's you know. And in fact, in my book and in a lot of my writing, I talk about that a lot. I mean, the idea of creating value, and that's why I'm here this morning. I mean, uh, a lot of people think they should be working for a living, and I think that's a really, really bad idea. Um, you said you said that this podcast, having this podcast, did a lot for you, and I'm betting a lot of what it did for you was change your mindset from a work mindset to a create value mindset. No question. And and no question that's that's a huge life-changing thing when you when you say I shouldn't be working for a living, what I should be doing is creating value for other people, and and that's the heart of capitalism. I mean, if if you ask me to put capitalism into a really short thing that differentiates it from socialism or fascism or communism or any other system, I would say this what we want to do is create a reality where we help everyone find what they're really good at. And we don't do that very well. In schools, we don't fail people enough. Now that sounds horrible, but when kids get through when kids go Through school and think they're good at everything, they aren't learning what they're really good at. Okay, well, that's true, but when you fail somebody in art and give them an A in math, you're saying something important. You're saying, you know what? Maybe you shouldn't try and be an artist. Maybe you'd be better off going into mathematics. And then the second thing is help everybody find their bliss. Find what they really love doing. And then take those two things and create, use them to create value for other people. That's like my ideal world. That's what I'd like to see us all be doing is finding what we're good at, what we love doing, and then use that to create value for others. And don't even think about working and don't think about money. That those aren't the issues. Now, my experience has been, I've observed that people who do that tend to succeed financially, but some don't. I mean, and but the ones I know are okay with that. I said I'm a musician, I've got some friends that are jazz musicians, and they typically don't do great financially, but but they're happy, they love doing jazz, and in a socialist state, somebody would say, No, well, you're not making enough money, so you have to do some other kind of music because you're not making money doing what you want to do, and to me, that's horrible. There, we should be okay doing art for art's sake, but when you're doing art for art's sake, you're not doing it for money's sake, and so you may not make money doing it, and that's okay, and that's why people talk about income inequality, and they're just dead wrong. Income inequality is a necessary outcome of freedom. If we all get to do what we want, we're all gonna make different choices, and those different choices are gonna lead us in different directions, and some are gonna lead to more income than others. And I would also argue that most of the or the most successful wealthy people are doing exactly that. I I do not believe that Elon Musk is doing what he's doing for money. The kinds of things he does make it clear that that's not what he's doing, he's out there trying to create cool stuff, and yeah, he makes a ton of money doing it, but that I don't think he even thinks about the money. And when Bill Gates started, he wasn't thinking about money, he was thinking, I love coding, I'm gonna try and create this really cool operating system, and came up with Windows, and you know, that's a great thing, and in fact, right now I'm talking to you on a PC running Windows on Starlink. We couldn't be having this conversation literally if it weren't for Bill Gates and Elon Musk. They made our conversation possible, and so and all the people that are listening to us couldn't be listening to us if it weren't for them. So, who am I to say they're making too much money? SPEAKER_01: No, I've yeah, I I'm with you, I'm with you on that. That's people who it probably don't have any, they kind of feel like you know what, we need to have we need to share, we need to share because they don't have any. SPEAKER_00: But their problem really is is that they aren't they aren't thinking about creating value. If they did that, I mean maybe they would go out and create a podcast, maybe they would do something that they loved and were good at, and tried to find a way to make things work for themselves, but working is not the answer. Working is a drag, and you can doesn't pay. I can go out in my yard today and fill dig a bunch of holes and fill them up again, and I won't make a dime because I've created no value, I've done I've wasted a bunch of time, and unfortunately, that's what a lot of people are doing at work every day. SPEAKER_01: Hello, Doug. I think we have time for a couple more questions, hopefully. I'm having I'm having fun here. Let me try to honor your time. So I'll do my best with these. Uh, what do you think, Dr. Doug, is the most surprising thing in your book? Because you already hit me with a couple things that I didn't know were in your book that I'm like, wow, this book is gonna be a good read. What's what's something you think is surprising in this book that people who are perhaps watching listening right now would have no idea that you're sharing in that book? Do you have something like that? A juicy chip. SPEAKER_00: I think there's a lot of it in there. I guess probably we've sort of hinted at it, but I think one of the things that that I think is really well, I couldn't. I mean let's go with this. I think I got a better idea. Most people don't understand how wonderful capitalism has been. They whine about it and stuff, but they're dead wrong. And I can pretty much prove that. If if we look at per capita GDP, that is how much stuff every person creates, that's a really also a really good measure of how much people get. Well, if we look back at that from the year one to the year 1500 or so, per capita GDP didn't change a drop. Now, let's let your listeners think about that a minute. The amount of stuff people had available to them, their economic life didn't improve at all for 1500 years. Now, it probably went back further than that, but that's as far as we've got records. But that that's astonishing. Now, what happened to change that? Well, there were some between 1500 and 1700, 1800-ish, there were some minor inclusions of capitalism. Capitalism started to sort of embryonically begin, and in that short period, per capita GDP increased 40 percent. That is, the average person was 40 percent better off than they were 300 years before that. Now, 40% better off, that's huge. That's huge, but that's nothing, it got way better, and it got better here in the US because this was the first country built on capitalism, and we have patents built into our constitution, no other country had ever done that, and one of the things you have to have in order to have a growing economy is a way for entrepreneurs to protect their work, and the US provided that and plus we built our everything on free markets and democracy, but that's also just huge, and so from 1820 to about now everybody in the world is 18 times better off than they were. 18, and that's the whole world, but here in the US, it's closer to 40 times better off. Yeah, capitalism is has completely changed the world, even going back as to only as far as 1950. In 1950, 38 percent of the world lived in extreme positive in extreme poverty. Now we're down to nine percent, and it's getting better every day, and so you don't hear about this stuff, right? No, you don't hear about this stuff. People don't understand that with that how much capitalism gives us. Look around your house, listeners. Take a look around. How much did you get from government and how much did you get from capitalists? And I'm guessing you're not gonna find much the government gave you. I actually did the numbers on Jeff Bezos, Amazon. Amazon's saves the average American two to three thousand dollars a year. So the guy became a billionaire, but he gave me a free two thousand two or three thousand dollars a year, and I'm gonna complain? What kind of craziness is that? It's it's it's insanity. It's saying I'm mad at that guy because he's rich for giving me money. And people talk about taxing the rich. Does anybody really think that taxing Jeff Bezos, the government could take money from him and give me two or three thousand dollars a year extra? No. I mean, they might give me a couple of bucks if they did that, but they're not going to give me two or three thousand dollars a year. If you take away the Jeff Bezos, you got to take away that two or three thousand dollars a year from me. Again, we talked about Elon Musk. How much time and money does Elon Musk save us every day? How much time and money does Jeff Bill Gates save us every day? And if you look at the 10 richest people in the world, they're all like that. They're all Americans, and they all got there, not by inherited wealth or cheating people, but by building companies that helped all of us. SPEAKER_01: This is the fresh perspective, Dr. Doug, man. Thank you for coming in and sharing this, man. This has been uh very, very insightful. I really appreciate you, man. It's been delightful. You guys that are uh listening and not watching on the screen right now, we have it up early in the episode is Dr. Doug's website where you can find his work and his new his new book, why socialism struggles.com. No spaces, why socialism struggles.com. Check it out, and again, sir, thanks for being here and being a part of this conversation. I learned a lot from you today, man. I'm so grateful that you were here, and I'm I'm glad you're continuing to kind of uh bust some of the myths that are floating on our head that people have been getting fed, that are clearly not the truth. So, thank you again for your time and for sharing your insights, sir. SPEAKER_00: Thank you for your thoughtful questions. SPEAKER_01: Pleasure of mine. So if you're watching and listening for the very first time, Dr. Doug and myself on this show. Thanks again for making us part of your week. We're live on YouTube, LinkedIn, and Facebook right now as we speak. This is Dr. Doug Cardell, the author of Why Socialism Struggles. I'm Mr. U. Have a great day. Thanks again for watching and listening. Check this man out, he knows what he's talking about. Have a good day.

Keep listening

More from the show

Image
Title