They Call Me Mista Yu
← All episodes

When You Stop Trusting Yourself: Finding Your Voice Again | Reese Wilson

20:20

Have a question or thought for Mista Yu? Text or leave a voicemail for the show and he’ll answer it personally on the Inspiration Station or They Call Me Mista Yu. With your Permission, We'll even play your message live on the air!

What happens when keeping the peace means losing yourself?

In this episode of They Call Me Mista Yu, I sit down with Reese Wilson, author of The Black Cup, for a deeply personal conversation about self-trust, identity, survival, resilience, and finding your way back to your own voice.

Reese spent decades in a marriage where her perspective, worth, and abilities were repeatedly questioned. Over time, she learned to distrust her own judgment and became exceptionally skilled at keeping the peace—even when doing so meant silencing herself.

Her story became the foundation for The Black Cup, a seemingly ordinary story that unfolds into something much bigger: a journey through survival, self-discovery, and triumph.

In this conversation, we explore:

  • How capable people can slowly lose trust in themselves
  • The hidden cost of constantly keeping the peace
  • Recognizing when you've abandoned your own voice
  • Why intelligent, strong women can still struggle with self-doubt
  • Rebuilding confidence after prolonged emotional erosion
  • The difference between peace and simply avoiding conflict
  • Learning to trust your instincts again
  • Finding identity after a major life transition
  • Using storytelling to make sense of difficult experiences
  • Rediscovering joy after loss
  • Making sense of chaos without being defined by it
  • Finding the courage to ask, "What's next?"

Reese brings an important perspective to a conversation that reaches far beyond one person's story.

Sometimes the hardest person to hear is yourself.

And sometimes rebuilding your life begins with something deceptively simple:

learning to trust your own voice again.

Support the show

In this episode

Read the transcript
SPEAKER_01: If you spend years trying to keep the peace in your mind and in relationships, but slowly realize you lost your voice in the process, this is the episode for you. Today I'm joined by the author of The Black Cup, a story of survival, self-discovery, and ultimately finding your way back to yourself. She specializes in helping capable people that have been questioning their own judgment find clarity and rediscover their joy. Let's get to the stage. Reese, thanks for joining the show. Appreciate your story. SPEAKER_00: Yeah, thanks for having me. I'm excited to be here. SPEAKER_01: Same here, same here. Let's go ahead and jump in. So, one of the things that uh we deal with on a lot of our content, a lot of personal development, spiritual development type uh topics. Uh, in your case, it seems like you seem to be an expert at keeping the peace. Not a great job description, I don't think, but from what I'm hearing from you, which at the expense of losing your own voice. What do you how does somebody who's intelligent, capable, confident gradually get to that place where they no longer trust their own judgment? What do you think? SPEAKER_00: Well, it's one little story at a time that you tell yourself. It's one moment at a time because it's easy to explain away one incident. And when you when you come up against incident after incident after incident, and each one gets explained away and put in a little box and put on a shelf, then you don't you don't look at the pattern anymore. You you're you're too focused in on each individual incident. And so over time, you're telling yourself these things have been taken care of when in reality they have not. They've just been explained away. SPEAKER_01: It's really good. It's really good. This is an interesting topic because a lot of folks have been at the at the place where they have so much trauma in their life, they have so much challenge that trusting yourself is is hard because they don't even know who's talking, they don't know if they're the origin of the voices, they don't know if this if it's if it's theirs emotions or if it's their emotions or somebody else's. So it's a really tough subject, but I want to get into some of the work that you've been doing. What is the black cup? Talk to us about that. What about the black cup? SPEAKER_00: The black cup is what I call my origin story. SPEAKER_01: Okay. SPEAKER_00: So it is the story of how I lost my voice. It is, it tells the story when I met my second husband and fell in love with him and felt like he was absolutely the left of my life. I was married to him for 24 years. But over those 24 years, I tell the story of uh some of the behaviors that he had that I explained away. And you kind of come along this journey with me of me starting to question my own understanding of things, my own memory, how I need to handle this situation in order to keep the peace. And so the reader is sort of discovering with me how this actually happens, how a person is uh manipulated into a place where they no longer trust their own voice. So that is really what the story is about, and then getting out of it and and starting to listen to myself again and starting to trust myself again and that process. SPEAKER_01: That's really good. Why the metaphor of the cup? Why did you decide to pick that as opposed to other items you could have used? SPEAKER_00: Because there's a specific story that has to go with it. And the very first chapter tells you about the story. There was this this moment, right? There's sometimes it's little moments that that tell a big, a big story, right? And there was this moment where we had been married for 24 years and he had been giving me the silent treatment for several weeks. And he he comes in uh to my room and he brings me a cup of coffee and and he tells me we need to talk, which, you know, on the surface might seem like a sweet gesture, but I have this weird thing where I love my coffee in a white cup. I don't know why, it's just my thing. And he brought me this coffee in a black cup. And I looked at that cup and I thought, 24 years, does he not know me? Have I not allowed him to know me? Does he know? And he's just testing me to see if I'll complain. All of these questions came up for me, and all of a sudden I realized like a black cup is making me question my entire relationship. There's a problem here. SPEAKER_01: Wow, what a powerful metaphor. Your book styles are amazing. I mean, I'm I'm excited to hear more about this, if possible. What do you think we writing this story kind of revealed to you about you? I get a lot of authors that come on our show and they want to do the circuit, I guess, but I'm a different host, as many are finding out. So I'm gonna go a little bit deeper than that. You find out so many things that's just like wow. Some people find out they wrote a book and don't even really know why they did it even now. Some people are buying it and they don't even know really why with with depth and substance why they wrote the book. What did that story or revealing that story, I should say, speak to you about you? SPEAKER_00: Well, for one thing, I when I started writing the book, I didn't plan to actually publish. I I knew from the beginning I was writing the book for me. Uh, because having my voice silenced, I needed to say it out loud to me. And for me, that was, you know, on paper. We do a lot of times when you go through trauma, you're encouraged to journal and write things down, or even write a letter to somebody and then burn it, you know, those types of things. So we know that writing is is therapeutic. The journaling ended up being, it was just a little too abstract for me. So I started to tell the story. And it was part way through the story. I was taking a creative creative writing class, and the teacher told me, you really need to tell this story. And I told her, I'm not sure that I want to. I don't know if I want it out in the world, you know, people that I know are gonna read this. And yeah, and but as I was in this process, I realized that I saw these things, but I didn't think anybody else would see them the way that I did. And as I'm sharing bits and pieces of the book, you know, the teacher tells me, at least finish writing the book, like at least finish the story before you decide if you're gonna publish or not. Because I really learned that my gut was right all along. And other people do see it even more extreme than I did. I I I would have these moments where I'm, you know, sitting around with some girlfriends, having a glass of wine way after the fact. Because as I'm in this situation, I really didn't talk much about what I was going through. And I would tell this a story that I thought was kind of funny, you know, and then I would see this look of hum of absolute horror on my audience's face. Like, oh my goodness, I I'm so sorry that you had to deal with that. And I'm like, oh, I guess that was kind of bad, wasn't it? I was kind of laughing about it, you know. So I realized that I had really made light of a lot of things, I had explained a lot of things away, but my gut was telling me that it wasn't right. And in writing this book, I I learned even more so that I could trust my perception of things. SPEAKER_01: That's that's that's that's poignant. Hopefully we have time to come back to that one. But the the whole idea of keeping the peace, it really sounds good in theory, but when I hear stuff like this, I I think about I go to a time I wasn't even born. I go to the 1800s where the husband was in the coal mine, and women had to stay home and grab the milk from the milkman and raise the kids and make sure that they, you know, went to school and got book learning, you know. And a lot of things happened in those eras and even happening now in 2026, where people are keeping the peace. They're ignoring very dangerous warning signs, red flags, if you will, and they're ignoring it to make sure that they maintain uh not only what they think is stability and statements, even though it really isn't, but also keeping up the facade of the life that they've been showing people. And now they have to try to make sure they don't be won't be embarrassed by saying, you know what, this whole thing was alive for all these years and decades. Yeah. For you, keeping the peace. For some, it's managing their own everybody's emotions and making sure that everything stays stable and don't let the gases get too high and make sure that the whole house doesn't implode. But there's a cost that you pay for keeping the peace. What was that? SPEAKER_00: Well, the cost was is that I swallowed everything. I do feel like keeping the peace is important to a degree. There's a balance. You can't be the only one trying to keep the peace. It has to be a it has to be a joint effort. And when both people are are trying to keep the peace in a family, that's a good, that's a good dynamic, that's a good team. SPEAKER_01: We know what that's like. We understand. SPEAKER_00: Um but but when it's only you and you're the only one, then what happens is you just have to swallow and swallow and swallow mistreatment and manipulation and lies and and it it comes out in other ways. You you can't swallow that forever. It's like swallowing poison and expecting it not to affect your body. It's gonna come out in your body, you know, in your health, in your mental health. So it all of those things were affected in me by trying to keep the peace. SPEAKER_01: Oh, definitely, definitely. I think I'm not misreading this when I understand from your story and your journey. It seems like you kind of have the same fascination I have about smart, capable women who have gotten to the place where they don't trust that judgment. Where they feel like, you know, keeping the pieces just best and they kind of uh diminish what they actually know, what they're actually seeing. What a sign that people are have gotten to the place where they start trusting themselves, like what you described. SPEAKER_00: Oh gosh. Signs to know that you've stopped trusting yourself. SPEAKER_01: Yeah, yeah. I mean, even if you have perhaps you're helping somebody else and you see the signs in them. Identify those signs for those who are watching and listening today. unknown: Go ahead. SPEAKER_00: Yeah, that's a that's a good question because the thing is, is when you're in it, you don't see it. But usually everybody else does. Usually there's people around you that see it. And and there's there's sometimes we don't see it because we don't want to see it, right? We we're afraid of what's gonna happen because if we admit that things are the way that our gut is telling us or the way that other people are telling us, then everything's gonna change. And maybe we've built this little safe fairy tale of the story that we want to live in. And the problem is you have to understand that that is fake. Just because you think you're living in this little fairy tale that you have built on the outside does not mean that that's actually what you're living in. And and there, and there's a lot of, you know, there's there's a lot of, I mean, one thing a lot of people have asked me is like, why didn't you leave sooner? And that's a really hard question. It's a common question. But like I said, it's these little, it's little things that cause you to mistrust your own judgment over time. So you don't leave because some you keep explaining away these these little incidents and all of these little things, and you're not looking at the pattern, and you're afraid of what if I leave this and what I go to is even worse. So, you know, singleness, single, being a single mom, what if that's worse than what I'm actually dealing with here? And there's a lot of of fear, and also you're being conditioned to not trust yourself. You're usually being told, you can't do this on your own. You need me. I love you more than anyone. No one else will love you the way that I do, nobody else will take care of you the way that I do. And you start to believe that. And so that's you know, that's the reason that people don't leave. So the signs is the signs are usually there, but you have to be ready to accept them. SPEAKER_01: Yeah, this goes really, really deep. This goes really deep. I've seen people know people who have been in in domestic violence situations, some physical, some emotional and mental, and some all of the above. And this kind of thing is happening. It sounds like a lot of your story is about rebuilding yourself after walking away from hurt, trauma, uh, etc. I don't I I this this is a big question to me. Maybe it's easy for you to answer, but it's a big one to me because the idea of trusting yourself, uh, it has so many layers and tentacles to it. Because a lot of the things that we think about, we feel, we respond to are cues that we get from the outside. It's not always a good thing, but we internalize it and we walk it out sometimes, knowing consciously and subconsciously. But for you, Reese, what does rebuilding your self-trust actually look like in everyday life? What's that look like? SPEAKER_00: Oh man. Doing things even though I'm scared to do them, doing things even though I'm not sure that I can, and figuring, you know what, if I fall on my face, any examples of that, Reese? Absolutely. Oh, let me let me give you one. So I really I woke up one day, five o'clock in the morning, and the house is quiet, and I'm laying there by myself, and I, you know, I'm reeling in my head about what am I gonna do? Like, what do I do with my life? What and I had no idea. What I really wanted was to be a wife and a mother, and I loved that role. It's just the partner I had did didn't wasn't working. And so I'm like, well, stepping away from the thing that I really wanted because it wasn't working. So what do I go towards? And I had no idea. Um, but but there was one thing I knew I wanted to do. I wanted to go to Yellowstone National Park. And seems like a weird, random thing. But when you're single and you're thinking about taking on a trip like that by yourself, most people would say, Oh, I can't, I can't do that. I can't drive across country by myself and and and I was gonna camp. So, but I I that morning I thought, you know what? I'm gonna do it. And I opened up my computer and I looked up, I found a campsite, and I booked it. And then I thought, oh my God, now what? I don't have a plan. I don't have you know, I've got four months to plan this. And I did it. And I planned it. I ended up finding a good friend of mine, went with me, and her and I, we I bought this little teardrop trailer and fixed it up, got it ready, stocked it, got it hooked up to my little SUV. On the way there, the car broke down, the alternator went out. We had to spend the night in a town that we I wasn't prepared to spend the night in. So I didn't really have a hotel picked out. The taillights stopped working on the trailer, actually, fell out of the trailer. There was wires hanging out in the trailer. So there's no taillights. We pulled into a Walmart and I bought bike flashing bike lights and glued them onto the back, flashing, and off we went. And you know what? I made it. I made it to Yellowstone. I saw the buffalo, the buffalo, I saw the geysers, you know, all of that, and and made it home. And I thought, okay, everything that could go wrong went wrong. And look what I still did. Look what happened. And that one was a big one for me that I was like, I can figure this stuff out if I need to. And I don't need somebody that I have to call to rescue me. I can figure it out. SPEAKER_01: I love that a lot. This is the place in our show where we do what we call the mirror check question. It's an opportunity for reflection for not only our guests and me, but also for our listeners and viewers watching live or on replay. So we're talking about rebuilding, we're talking about next steps. It's kind of part of your story. What would you say to somebody who's watching, listening today, who knows their old life doesn't fit anymore? And they have no idea what the next chapter is supposed to look like. I have people that come on and answer questions like this. And I recognize that a lot of people don't really take the time to really think about this kind of thing. They just give you an answer to kind of just think it's good, but you're giving it to who knows how many people are gonna be watching, listening to this live on the replay. They have no idea what the next chapter is gonna look like. Next steps have no idea, but they but they do know their old life no longer fix anymore. SPEAKER_00: Yeah. SPEAKER_01: What are you saying to them? SPEAKER_00: I say start doing something. Anyway, it's like a car. If you're sitting in the driveway trying to turn it, it's not gonna go anywhere. It's got to start moving forward. And it doesn't matter if you turn the car down the wrong street, you're gonna figure out down that street that you've gone the wrong way and you can turn around and go back. But if you just sit in the driveway, you never know where you're not going anywhere. So it start with something small, like a trip to Yellowstone, or you know, take a class. It doesn't have to be that you're making a choice for something that's gonna figure out your whole life. That doesn't, that's not the point. The point is to start moving and start going forward. And if you realize that you've gone the wrong way, redirect. Everything you do, you you get something from. Nothing is a waste of your time. Nothing is a waste of your time. And so just just start with something. Start something small and start moving. SPEAKER_01: Sounds really simple. Thank you again, Reese, for being on here and sharing those pearls of wisdom and your incredible story. We definitely appreciate it. SPEAKER_00: Yeah, thank you so much for having me. SPEAKER_01: My pleasure. So the episode resonates with you at all. I really hope it has. You can find Reese on the website up on the screen, unstoppable hyphenlife.com. Unstoppablelife.com. Of course, you can find that her book, The Black Cup, on our website. You heard the story. It sounds amazing already. The Black Cup is an incredible title and incredible story to go with it. Of course, if you don't mind helping us out, jump to our YouTube channel, youtube.com at the call me Mr. You. Drop us a follow, subscribe there. Reese, you do the same thing to help us out. We definitely appreciate that. And don't forget, guys, we always end the show with this. It's not gonna change. Don't forget, the difference between who you are and who you could be is finding what you do every single day. That's Reese Wilson. I'm Mr. U. This is the Call Me Mr. You, the flagship and the podcast. Thanks again for watching and listening. Have a good one.

Keep listening

More from the show

Image
Title