Read the transcript
Speaker 1: Boom.
Welcome back to T3.
We are in the house at the
Thursday night thing.
I'm your boy, mr U Herbs in the
house, sheens in the house.
Gentlemen, how are you guys
doing tonight on this glorious
evening?
Speaker 2: I just wanted
everybody to think I froze, I'm
good, it's a beautiful night.
Speaker 1: It works every time,
you guys good weather-wise.
Everything good with everybody.
Speaker 2: Yeah.
Busy work day, that's it, but
otherwise good.
Speaker 1: That's good news.
All right, it wasn't a summon,
there was a request and you said
yes, so thank you day.
That's it, but otherwise good.
That's good news.
All right, it wasn't a summon,
there was a request and you said
yes, so thank you.
We're going to chat with you in
a little bit Some keen insights
in some areas that we want to
talk about.
Before we get into that, some
quick, exciting news we started
a partnership with the SportCoin
Network.
Sportcoin, in case you're not
aware of them, they're a brand
new sports network that's
dedicated to helping fans like
you and I find quality sports
content while helping content
creators grow their media
presence.
Also, if you're tired of
hearing the same voices, the
same talking heads on the big
networks, break away and find
some refreshing new sports
content, like this show and the
Herb and Raj podcast, sports and
Money podcast and many other
exciting options.
And, of course, the Sport Coin
Network is dedicated to
partnering with those kind of
content creators to give you a
more broad opportunity to find
some quality sports content.
So shout-out to Sport Coin
Network.
We're excited about being
partnered with these guys and
looking forward to big things.
All right, so we got Cat Pools
in the house.
We're going to talk about you
in a little bit, cat.
We need your help there, so
hold on for a little bit, all
right?
So Regina's in the house.
I can keep you guys missed her
shoulder.
She was on about two weeks ago.
Fantastic insights on college
players and and injuries and
just a whole human biology.
So she's a wizard that and
we're going to have her on to do
some more stuff, maybe even
human biology.
So she's a wizard that and
we're going to have her on to do
some more stuff, maybe even
next week if all things work out
together.
Our Raj she's one half of the
Herb and Raj podcast.
You can find them on YouTube
and SamuCast on social media.
Every Tuesday evening at 8 pm
CST, he's holding down the
comment section for us.
That's our sniper out there.
Take him down.
Raj, protect us now.
He got our six, all right.
So we had Kat come on.
She's a big New Orleans Saints
fan.
I'm going to have you talk
about that poll in a second, but
not yet I want to do the second
poll first.
We had two poll questions that
got a lot of votes and a lot of
interesting answers.
The second one was our trade
deadline poll.
Which team had the best trade
deadline move.
There was several of those, but
I picked four out of the ones
that we saw.
So Darius Smith, who's been
well-known to be with the
Packers for a long time on the
D-line.
He was a big part of why Aaron
Rodgers won games in his last
couple of years there.
Z Smith was one of the big
reasons why he was tremendous on
their defense.
He went to the Detroit Lions,
which is like they needed more
help right.
So he went over to Marshawn
Lattimore.
That's probably the biggest
name coming from the Saints.
You know the Saints are already
packing it in for the season.
There's not a whole lot of
they're trimming fat wherever
they can now.
So he went to the Washington
Commanders, which is a very
powerful move.
Most of the guys that the
commanders are on one or
two-year deals.
We check their contract length
out.
So next year is going to look a
lot different, but he'll be
there perhaps a little bit
longer than that, so he's going
to be a part of their growth as
a franchise.
Mike Williams was formerly under
Aaron Rodgers on the Jets.
They traded him to Pittsburgh,
which is probably good for
George Pickens.
I think the jury's out on how
it's going to affect their
offense, whether it's going to
dramatically improve it or
improve by a wee bit.
I'm not really sure yet.
It's hard to tell me.
If you guys have insights on
that, I don't know.
And the last one was Cam
Robinson, which I thought was a
huge move.
Going to Minnesota, darethal
went out and everybody was
afraid that Don was going to get
killed and they found a guy
like Karen Robinson out there
waiting.
This guy, he's not a bum, he's
not a scrub.
I mean Karen Robinson can play
his position and to find him out
there available, that's some
real good fortune for the
Minnesota Vikings.
So we had the poll that went
out and by a long mile, marshawn
Lattimore to the commanders
51.5% of the vote, which is not
surprising.
Xavier Smith was behind him at
30.9, and then Cam Robinson and
then lastly was Mike Williams
all the way at the back of the
line going to Pittsburgh.
So any thoughts on that poll?
Do you guys agree with those
decisions that Lattimore was the
biggest move?
If you do, why or why not?
Speaker 3: I mean for me.
I agree with Lattimore.
That was my pick.
I do like exactly what you said
about Cam Robinson.
I think he's going to be the
one that may pay the most
dividends for the team.
But Washington had to do
something.
They made a decision.
They've got a weak defensive
backfield.
That's probably the one
weakness that showed for them
for the last couple of weeks.
I think having a lot more in
there definitely helps.
I think just the time and the
level that he's played at will
make them step up a little bit.
But I agree with you.
I think the Ken Robinson one is
the biggest surprise to be able
to find somebody like that.
A surprise, um, to be able to
find somebody like that again.
The the big surprise for me
during this trade deadline is
nobody had to pay a lot to get
some of this talent.
You know, in years past some
people have dropped some big
deals.
Everyone was going for fifth
and sixth round picks this year.
I mean of all the years where
you thought you'd have some
people that had to pay some high
prices.
You know I was surprised.
Speaker 1: Me too.
Speaker 2: It seemed like
Lattimore went for the biggest
prize and then Jonathan Mingo
was second.
Somehow.
Speaker 1: Yeah, what kind of
deal was that?
Speaker 2: I'll answer your
question first.
But that one has to get some
love in here because that's one
of these.
He went for more than any of
the other wide receivers.
That's already crazy, but it
has to get some love in here
because that's like one of these
.
He went for more than like any
of the other wide receivers.
So like that's already crazy
but it has to be thrown out
there.
So no, I liked a lot of more
move.
I think it's.
It's interesting because this
is not a move that they were
ever thinking at the beginning
of the year and then all of a
sudden their record is what it
is and now they're like hey guys
, we can win.
So now they make it the Zedaria
Smith.
I love that move because I am
rooting for Detroit a little bit
and they had to replace Hutch,
so you know that it was going to
happen.
So I see why Lattimore was the
first one, but Detroit was going
to get an edge rusher somewhere
.
We just didn't know what name,
but someone was getting fired if
they didn't get some money.
So that's how that works.
Cam, it was with Alabama, so of
course I was watching that one,
and Pittsburgh was linked to
every wide receiver out there.
You know going back to Brandon
Ayuk, so them getting Mike
Williams.
It doesn't get as much love
because it feels like they got
whoever was left over.
But I feel better for Mike
Williams because he had to get
away from the Jets.
You know, once Aaron Rodgers
buried him, that was it for him.
Speaker 1: So it had to happen.
So you guys like the move.
Okay, clearly you like it for
Mike Williams, I do too.
I think it's better.
I think Russell Williams is
going to give him a lot more
opportunities.
But as far as the whole team
for Pittsburgh itself, do you
feel like Mike Williams is good
for Pittsburgh as a whole?
Speaker 2: I do, because they
needed a number two.
Pickens has really emerged as a
number one, a really good deep
threat and a contested ball
catcher.
They had to have somebody else.
The offense has looked better
since Russell Wilson had gotten
there.
So you know my little surprise
at that.
Does it look bad for Justin
Fields?
Yeah, there's a lot to unpack
as far as that goes, but the
offenses look better.
They needed another weapon.
So if Mike Williams was
available and he's only coming
in to be like if they were
saying, hey, Mike Williams is
coming to be our number one, I'm
like I don't know about that,
but coming in to be the number
two, fine with that.
Speaker 1: So fine with that, so
I'm okay.
He's better than van jefferson.
I think anybody can agree with
that.
All right, go ahead, shane,
anything else on that?
Speaker 3: no, I think, exactly
like herpes, that the other
thing to think about with mike
williams is I mean, when
pittsburgh was I?
I mean you can't even say when
they were more competitive,
because they, like with mike
tomlin, they've been competitive
the whole time.
But this is what they do.
They normally have that one big
wide receiver.
They're not normally great
speed guy.
They'll have one speed guy and
then they'll have one.
Then they normally load up on
heights, on wide receiver.
Mike williams fits that need um.
You know he he's gonna fill
those roles.
They have a good tight end.
Uh.
They have a deep, decent
offensive line.
Um frazier for them out of west
virginia has been a great draft
pick um, so I think they're
happy in that way.
Uh, I was surprised that, like
you said, though, for them to
have been involved with every
wide receiver that's been out
there.
If mike williams is what I get
out of the deal, I'm not
necessarily happy if I'm
pittsburgh, but I think he will
be a good fit for williams.
Anything that gets me out of
the jets um would have been a
plus.
And, like her said, as,
basically, as soon as aaron
rogers mentions you, that means
the bus is coming to run you
over, so you might as well get
out while you can.
Um, he's not going to get the
ball to you again and he's
definitely not going to take any
chances a year away yeah, yeah.
Speaker 2: You feel like
Pittsburgh knew that Williams
was always going to be available
, so they kicked the tires on
everyone else available and then
just said, all right, this is
because everyone has known
Williams was out for weeks now.
It just feels like they were
okay.
Here's what's left.
Let's go get him.
And Pittsburgh has a habit of
making their number two wide
receivers a lot of money.
Not with him elsewhere.
But everybody who's a number
two seems to sign somewhere else
and then severely disappoint.
So I think he'll be fine there.
Speaker 1: Well, culture-wise, I
think it would be good for
Williams.
As far as downfield blocking
issue that they already had with
Pickens, I don't know if
Williams will solve that.
He did some of that in Los
Angeles, san Diego I forgot
which one he was in, but I'll
just say Los Angeles, for lack
of a better word, but Los
Angeles.
He did some of that there, but
more than Pickens did.
But I don't know if he's going
to do that so much in Pittsburgh
.
I hope he does because they
really need it because Pickens
wasn't doing it.
West Coast wins in the house.
Good evening, what's up.
Will you be joining us?
Always appreciate you.
The running wrestling part of
boy big mike's in the house.
What's up, fella.
Lady alfrey in the house.
What's up, lady, all right, dad
, we coming to you right now.
I don't know what to say.
I think this is for.
We're coming to you now, all
right.
So our second.
Our first poll question was the
one that I'm like.
Huh, okay, the question was
about michael th.
Comments about Derek Carr and
Chris Olave.
I didn't bring any quotes.
If you guys have them, feel
free to share them.
I don't have any, but the gist
of it is that Michael Thomas was
no longer on the team now.
He was talking about how Derek
Carr's play was always an issue.
His decision-making was getting
people in trouble, specifically
wide receivers getting hurt,
and he said that Olave got hurt
because of those said decisions,
and he went into more detail.
He used some language that we
ain't going to use on this show
just don't do that.
But he kind of went into a lot
more detail.
But I asked the question on our
Twitter poll was Thomas 100%
correct in his assessments about
Chris Alave and Derek Carr?
Was he mostly correct or
totally incorrect?
Now, if you watch any Saints
games, I feel like you should be
able to say you know what I
vote.
He's 100% correct.
I asked this beautiful young
lady, kat Poole, one of our fans
and friends of the show.
She's a big Saints fan, diehard
to our heart, and I asked her
the same question and she was in
total agreement.
And I missed something.
I misunderstood that she was in
total agreement that Mike
Thomas was right about
everything that he said.
I thought it was going to be a
landslide.
When I hit send, I said you
know what?
Nobody's going to vote for any
of this other stuff.
It's going to be 100% because
they saw the game.
They saw Derek Carr and what he
was doing and not doing.
They saw it.
Here's the results of the poll
41.5% said 100% Mike Thomas is
right.
That's not the winning vote.
43.4% said Mike Thomas is kind
of correct about most stuff, and
.
15.1,.
I don't know who you are, where
you came from.
If you're out there, please
speak up.
Tell me why you said Mike
Thomas was totally wrong,
because I don't understand how
Totally wrong, like nothing he
said was right.
So let you guys chime in, and
then I want to hear from Kat.
Go ahead.
Speaker 2: So I've never watched
Carr enough to really really
look into this, but it's because
you mentioned about quotes.
So one of the first thing you
look up with, you know, is
keshaun johnson speaking for
michael thomas, and he's
basically saying michael thomas
is bringing this up because car
got thomas hurt as well.
So it's like I don know it's
too a big number if you're a
wide receiver, yeah, but that's
why they're saying that.
And then you know the ball that
got a lot of hurt was a
terrible ball.
So that kind of feels like
where it comes from, but it
definitely seemed personal.
So it makes sense if Thomas is
actually blaming Carr for
something.
I just disagree with handling
it.
You know, like if you hurt me
with the ball, I'm going to go
tell you I'm not going to take
to Twitter forever, but that's a
whole another subject.
Speaker 1: Is he on the team
right now?
Speaker 2: I think he's in
witness protection.
I haven't heard from him.
Speaker 1: I'm just wondering if
he's speaking like that and
he's on the team.
I didn't think he was.
That makes more sense.
Question.
Speaker 3: Yeah Well, I mean I
agree with her that I don't know
if that's the way that I would
have attacked it, but Michael
Thomas didn't back down.
And then he not only did he
talk about that, he's not the
only one that got hurt, he also
mentioned other people.
He got hurt.
Michael Thomas thomas said you
know, you got your boy leading
the league and receiving.
You had to throw the ball to
him 180 times for him to get 100
catches.
You know.
That's telling you how bad of a
quarterback you are.
I think if you ask dennis allen,
uh, derrick carter is the only
quarterback that's gotten down
sound fired.
So it doesn't matter what team
dennis allen's on you, let
derrick carter be only
quarterback that's gotten Dennis
Allen fired.
So it doesn't matter what team
Dennis Allen's on you, let Derek
Carter be your quarterback.
He's going to get you fired.
He's proven that.
Two teams two for two on that.
Like Herb said, I don't know if
this is the way that I attack
it.
There's definitely direct
things that Michael Thomas has.
There's probably more that he's
not even mentioning.
I don't think that Derek Carter
was ever the real choice in new
orleans and I don't think he's
played that well and I think
even at his best in the raiders,
I think wide receivers would
still tell you that he doesn't
throw a great ball and he didn't
put us in great position.
Um, so I don't think any of
it's wrong.
I don't think any of it's wrong
tell.
Speaker 1: I don't think any of
it's wrong.
Tell me the truth now, Be as
honest as you possibly can.
When that season started and
they had those two games, was it
two or three games where Carl
was lighting it up?
Speaker 3: Tell me how you guys
felt Ron Game was lighting it up
.
Speaker 1: He was throwing two
brother.
Watch them games.
Speaker 3: He was stunning.
I watched those games.
I'm telling you.
He lost a center, two guards
and a tackle and he started
throwing the ball all over the
place he was accurate, though,
and that's something we haven't
been seeing.
Speaker 1: How do you guys feel
about that?
When you saw it, do you feel
like, ah, this is just fool's
gold, or do you think something
was cooking out here?
Your honest thoughts definitely
more fool's gold, or do you
think something was cooking?
Speaker 2: out here your honest
thoughts, definitely more fool's
gold.
You just don't ever see.
Like car is your long-term guy,
you know?
And and to that point also it's
kind of like goes back to
originally what I said how many
times do you heard about, you
know, like if you go five games
in a row throwing great balls
right, and then one game you,
you get a wide receiver knocked
out.
We're probably going to
remember that one.
You know what I mean.
It just that number just seems
more significant there.
So it's not like you know, and,
but you just don't.
I guess you just don't see it
from a lot of your best
quarterbacks either.
You know what I mean, so that's
, that's going to be another
knock on him I think.
Speaker 1: I think I understand
what you're saying.
Go ahead, Shane.
Speaker 3: Yeah, I mean, carr's
never been a favorite of mine,
hasn't really depended on what
team he's played on.
I think he has talent and you
can get him to throw the short
passing game and that's okay.
But he's proven, when it comes
down to him he's going to lose
games for you.
You know whether it's with New
Orleans, orleans, where it's a
lot of smoke and magic, and you
have a great run game that
starts off for you and you let
him throw a lot of short passes
and try to get people around,
that's fine.
You know your job as a
quarterback is to win the game.
They don't care.
You know how you do it all the
time.
But you know there's not a lot
of people that are backing Carr
up.
That's another great indicator
in my mind.
You know that's a good point.
And Devontae Adams, you know,
played with him at Fresno State
and he definitely said, hey,
let's go play with Rodgers over,
go play with Carr.
You know he made that move in
vegas and car was already out,
like I, I don't think car has
ever been the one and I also
don't I don't know many saints
fans that ever thought that he
was.
I think herb makes a great
point.
I mean, I mean derrick car,
after his first couple years,
became one of those guys where
you're like, hey, that'd be a
great guy to have as my number
two.
Like, have him come in.
He's gonna know the offense,
he's gonna keep himself out of
trouble, we're gonna be okay.
But I think the teams that he's
been on they've constantly been
looking for the next
quarterback yeah, I think it
kind of goes to your other
question.
Speaker 2: you're gonna ask, mr
you, you just don't have a whole
lot of like, true, hey, hey,
this is my number one
quarterback guy.
You have a lot of quarterbacks
in the league right now that
you're like.
I mean, if everything else goes
right, this guy can win, but if
one of those other things is
failing, they're not the guy to
prop you up, you know, and like
car, yeah, if he has a great
running game and a great defense
, like you know, into the
quarterback, like yeah, can he
go out and give you some
insurance?
Running game and a great
defense, like you know, into the
quarterback, like yeah, can he
go out and give you some wins,
sure, but is he the guy that I'm
like is going to be my, you
know, superstar, carry a
terrible team?
Like no, I don't think that.
I don't think many people do.
Speaker 1: Yeah, let's play a
little fun game, cat.
I want to hear from you, cat,
on what you think the Saints
should be doing from here.
I don't think.
I think Herb and Shane are
hitting it.
Nobody ever thought that Carr
was going to be a long-term
solution by long-term if they
thought four years, I'd be
surprised.
I was thinking more like a
couple while they figured some
stuff out.
But I want to play a little
game here while Cat is thinking
about that answer.
Okay, so I'm going to give you
a quarterback and then, carr,
you tell me which one you rather
have.
Right, we've done it before.
Speaker 2: it's always fun, all
right, malik willis, derrick,
car wow malik willis her yeah,
because he's younger, I mean I
can at least maybe develop him.
Speaker 3: I feel like car is
who he is yeah, that, and he
came in and, exactly like we
said, he's the number two and he
filled in in Green Bay and kept
that team alive.
Speaker 1: Thank you for the
confidence right.
Speaker 2: Well, I don't.
I mean, I don't think Willis is
the number one, but I would
definitely keep him around.
And if I was going to keep one
of those two, I'm keeping Willis
around.
Speaker 1: And I'll be just
positive.
Speaker 2: No, but Willis is
probably not going to get
anybody killed because he
doesn't throw well enough stuff.
Speaker 1: We're not going to
have to worry about that, wow
Okay.
Jacoby Bissett, derek Carr.
Speaker 2: Yeesh, neither I'll
take one of you two.
We'll run the Wildcat.
Speaker 3: Yeah, exactly Extra
running back.
Speaker 1: So, shane, you
picking nobody too.
Speaker 3: I'm definitely not
taking Jacoby Brissett.
I've proven that time and time
again.
What does that mean?
Speaker 2: Okay, if I had one
game and I needed to win the
game right I would take Carr
over Brissett, because I feel
like there's at least more
upside with him than Brissette.
I think Brissette would play to
not lose you the game, but Carr
might actually try to go out
and win it.
Fair, I like that.
Speaker 1: Now we're thinking
baby, I like this, okay, yeah.
Speaker 2: I thought that's
where we were going, because
they should definitely be
starting over, but that's a
whole other.
Speaker 1: Yeah, I think they're
getting close to when Lattimore
left.
Speaker 2: But then they just
gave AK a big extension, so that
was kind of weird.
I'm sorry, go ahead.
Speaker 1: And don't forget it
was not more than a matter of
months ago that the Saints had
an elite defense, and now
they're giving people away.
That's kind of killing.
Derek Carr, marcus Mariota.
Speaker 2: Derek killing, derek
Carr Marcus, mariota Derek.
Carr, but so let's say this If
you were saying I could get them
both cheap, then I'll take
Derek Carr, but if you're like
you got to pay Derek Carr $20
million or Marcus Mariota $5
million, I'm taking Marcus
Mariota for here.
I'll just figure it out.
Speaker 1: Yeah, shane, you got
one.
Speaker 3: I go with Marcus.
Speaker 2: I feel like if my
team's decision was coming down
to that, we weren't winning the
Super Bowl anyway.
Yeah, if the exec comes in and
says, hey, we're going to get
Derek Carr or Marcus Mariota, I
was like, so we're in the middle
of a rebuild.
Like, what are we doing?
Speaker 1: All right, we'll keep
going.
Mack Jones, derek Carr, bam,
I'm talking, that's all that is
damn, I'm talking baby shane I,
I agree, uh, I mean I.
Speaker 3: I think mac jones got
the short end of a stick of a
terrible offensive unit in new
england.
Um, I'm not saying he's a
savior or anything right, but um
, when he had at least some
offensive weapons he looked okay
.
And then then you get rid of
everybody and you don't have an
offensive coordinator for two
years.
That makes it tough yeah you
know what my?
Speaker 2: thoughts about mac
jones.
We saw this at alabama.
He is great if you've got a
great structure around him, like
if you draw up a play and
you've got good playmakers, he
knows where the ball is supposed
to go.
So he won't thrive in every,
every environment.
But yeah, new england had just
basically like Bill Belichick
was just trying to prove
something to people Like who
hires two defensive coordinators
as an offensive coordinator
with a rookie coordinator?
None of that made sense.
Speaker 1: I don't know myself.
Just a handful more Gardner,
minshew, derek, carr.
Speaker 2: Derek Carr.
I've seen too much of him, it's
true.
Speaker 1: Oh man, like this
next one I got in front of me.
It created so many questions.
I'm like why don't you say just
I can't understand some of your
movements.
Speaker 2: I want to explain
what I said last week about
Minshew.
Like I always knew he was bad,
right, and I said that at the
beginning.
I said he's that guy who will
go out, win you a game or two
early in the season and then
just be bad the rest of the year
like that's Minshew.
But I watched the game and this
guy is like turning the ball
over, like he's being paid to do
it.
You know it's like hey, do we
want an interception or a fumble
here?
Maybe both.
Maybe I'll drop it.
Pick it up and throw it, like
he's just, like he just't care.
He spends more time on his
mustache than he does on the
game.
That's what I feel.
Speaker 1: Fair Sheeran, you got
a point on that one.
We're going to move on.
Speaker 3: No, I agree with Herb
on this.
I think Las Vegas has tried this
out, and I think, your record
with Derek Carr was better than
your record with Gardner Mischuk
.
So I think we have some actual
uh evidence on this one uh.
The other thing is, like I've
heard mentioned before, I think
Derek Carr can still win you a
game that, like, I'm not saying
that he's not an NFL quarterback
, but he's not the quarterback I
build around you know.
So, like, if you have to pick
him, do I think that, yes, you'd
be in a better spot than
Gardner-Mitchell?
There's no chance he's a better
selection in this.
Speaker 1: Kenny Pickett, derek
Carr.
Speaker 3: Derek.
Speaker 2: Carr.
Speaker 3: That's a tough one.
Speaker 1: You guys think that
Kenny Pickett is done, he has no
redeemable value.
That's what you're saying.
Speaker 2: I forgot where he
went.
Did he go to Philadelphia?
Speaker 3: Yeah, he's a backup
in Philly.
Speaker 2: Yeah.
Speaker 1: I don't know where
he's going to ever play, but
he's a backup, yeah, okay.
Speaker 2: I'll give you a
perfect like.
If Derek Carr was at Pittsburgh
, he could probably make that
work.
Good defense, decent running
backs.
We're not going to ask you to
do anything spectacular.
We're okay punting the ball.
That's a Derek Carr team.
Speaker 3: Yeah, he's.
I mean like, the way I like to
think of it is he's a
thermometer quarterback, like if
your team's hot he's going to
keep that temperature.
The same thing, he's not a
thermostat.
He's not a thermostat.
He's not like any of these
quarterbacks that's going to
drive your talent.
Derek Carr can play well in a
system that's built around him
with a lot of talent around.
Once that talent starts to drop
, he's not going to be able to
do anything plus for you.
He doesn't have like Lamar
Jackson all these years in
Baltimore, no weapons around.
Him.
Still wins games.
Brock Purdy, every wide
receiver that's been out no
running game still looks okay in
San Francisco.
Speaker 1: You know Cat Poole
right there, Tyson Hill is Ben
the better quarterback in the
world for the last three years.
I don't like him consistently
playing in that position.
That's the thing.
When he does that, we see a lot
of stuff get exposed.
I don't know what that's about,
maybe because he plays
different positions.
When he plays quarterback
consistently, like you're the
guy at quarterback all the time,
it doesn't look pretty.
Speaker 2: No.
I think he's more of a gimmick
quarterback for sure.
Speaker 3: I agree too, but
they're out of gimmicks, Like if
you pay Spencer Riddler, you
have him, you have.
Speaker 1: There's no Riddler.
There's no Riddler.
Speaker 3: Well, I'm combining
two quarterbacks that are both,
he's just combining two quarter
yeah.
I thought you were talking
about, like the cousin of the
Joker or something.
Speaker 1: Exactly what kind of
hybrid is this?
Speaker 3: but yeah, the worst
possible yeah, exactly, deon and
spencer rattler, both
quarterback.
Like the thing is, you're gonna
have a ton.
Right now derrick carr turns
the ball over.
So what's your biggest
complaint about Tyson Hill?
That he's going to turn the
ball over?
So if we're paying a real
quarterback value for Derek Carr
and he's going to give you 30
turnovers and Tyson Hill you pay
at like a tight end value and
he gets you 25 turnovers, what
have we lost by playing him?
Speaker 1: You know.
Speaker 3: That's where Derek
Carr runs into the problem.
Just like Herb said in the very
beginning, if I'm not paying
Derek Carr the money that I have
to pay him, then yeah, $5
million.
Yeah, okay, we can play some
ball with him, but you're paying
him as the number one
quarterback and he hasn't been a
number one quarterback in a
long time.
Speaker 1: Fair.
Let's jump into this quick
conversation.
I mean quick, maybe 10 at the
very worst.
The comments that brady made
tom brady, hall of fame, who's
now, uh, an announcer now doing
a fairly decent job at it, by
the way uh, he made a comment
about rookie quarterbacks and
how the game seems to be dumbed
down for them and it's kind of
uh, hurting the game and hurting
their development as
quarterbacks.
Now it's going to be hard to
dispute much of what he said
just because of his, uh, his
pedigree and what he's done at
the position.
All that he's seen, the, the
numbers and the records that he
has are still unbroken.
So we're giving, uh, the
benefit of the doubt with a lot
of that stuff.
But he's saying that the game's
been dumbed down.
Coaches in the NFL are not
challenging the young
quarterbacks.
They're kind of taking them for
where they are and kind of just
working with what they got
rather than coaching them and
developing them and training
them.
What are your thoughts on that?
Because we talked about it
before, about a rookie
quarterback coming out of
college and whether they should
sit under a veteran quarterback
for a while, however long that
is, or thrust them right into
the action and they learn better
that way.
You got coaches like the
Titans' Brian Callahan, who's an
ardent believer that they
should come out of college and
get thrown right into the fire.
He thinks it's better for them.
They're learning development
that way.
And you got other coaches who
make like a Matt LaFleur or a
Harbaugh, that kind of feel a
little different about that.
They want them to kind of have
that grooming and let them see
all they need to see in that
time, and Tom Brady credits that
for a big part of his
development.
What do you guys feel about
that?
Speaker 2: just generally
speaking, as well as Brady's
comments.
Brady, when Brady came out, he
didn't start right away either,
right, I mean he was stuck
behind.
It is an interesting thing.
I think there's like a lot of
elements at play.
So when you talk about the
coaches developing the
quarterbacks, the coach the
lifespan of a coach now is
getting shorter and shorter.
So when they get the guy,
they've got two choices.
All right, I could try and train
y'all this.
We'll probably lose a lot of
games, but maybe you'll get
valuable experience.
Or I could dumb this down Maybe
we'll all look good and maybe
I'll get to stick around a
couple more years, and I think
that kind of goes into it.
Plus, I don't think college is
helping.
I think college coaches are
kind of getting the same way.
We just need to win now.
So whatever I have to do to
utilize your skill set right now
is fine, and then the pro game
is way different and a lot of
them aren't keeping up.
So I think it's like a
collective effort where
everybody is like let me look
out for myself right now versus
let me actually train this guy
long.
But I just don't think there's
a lot of training going on in
the NFL at all.
Speaker 1: And Kat said that.
Before you get your comment in
Shane, kat said when you're
paying that much for a rookie,
do you want to see your money
sitting on the bench?
Is it their fault?
The price has gone up so much.
I get that there's pressure,
especially with teams that feel
as though they have to get
something done in a timely
manner, but you just never know
how it's going to turn out.
The Jaden Daniels situation is
kind of an anomaly.
I mean, he came in.
He has somebody in the room
which I guess in this case was
Mariota, who was considered a
veteran.
It kind of helped create an
environment for him to kind of
grow at the position, but he's
still starting though and he's
thriving at the position.
But he's still starting though,
and he's thriving at the
position.
You got people who, like EJ
Manuel, who didn't have the
opportunity to do that with
Buffalo he had Kevin Cole with
them guys that wasn't really
giving him the kind of
leadership that he needed and he
came out there, hurt his leg
and they tried to give him a
break and sit him down and they
didn't have nobody else that
could play at his level.
So they put him back in.
He hurt his other leg, so he
was already screwed from the rip
.
So it's like there's so many
different examples of this.
It's like what do you do with
that?
So, shane, go ahead and drop
your comments in there, brother,
and we'll keep on moving.
Man, what do you think?
Speaker 3: well, I think Herb
mentioned it.
I mean, the coaching cycle is
such a such a quick turnaround.
Yeah, you know how can you wait
?
Other problem is and I think
people talk about this way too
much is the NFL has always been
terrible at developing
quarterbacks.
Like that it's a proven fact
Like if they were better, then
these first-round draft picks
would show up better than they
do.
And they don't.
But the problem is is that
we're not developing
quarterbacks at all sorts of
levels, like Her her mentioned.
You watch college football these
days and there's a lot of
quarterbacks that don't have to
make the decisions for
themselves, they don't have to
do anything.
And then they get to the NFL
and they showed great athletic
talent and maybe some decent
numbers, but they can't explain
everything, they can't go
through the checks, they can't
go through what they need to,
and then you give a team to them
and expect them to be the ones
that are going to lead it and
they don't even know what's
going on and they don't develop
quarterbacks in the NFL.
We mentioned Tom Brady.
The thing is, drew Bledsoe had
that team winning games.
If Mo Lewis doesn't absolutely
destroy him to where he almost
ends up dead, brady doesn't
absolutely destroy him to where
he almost ends up dead.
Brady doesn't get to play and
Brady didn't blow the doors off
when he started and this is from
a Patriots fan and my fandom
started with Drew Bledsoe so
like that's a quarterback that
was developed.
You know he had to be ready and
Brady wasn't ready in the very
beginning and he wisely says you
know, I'm not ready, ready.
But you talk to even the
coaches that get a lot of credit
for developing quarterbacks,
like somebody like bruce arians,
and he even says the same thing
like you have to be talented, I
I can't.
No matter how much better I can
make you, you're still not
going to be great.
You know he talks about jameson
winston when Winston when he
had 30 interceptions but threw
for 5,000 yards.
That one year he's like yeah.
And then we finally got him
LASIK surgery, like who knew he
couldn't see the entire time.
I mean, how much developing are
you doing if you don't know
that your quarterback can barely
see?
Speaker 2: you know.
Speaker 3: The other thing is
you just see it in games.
There's less and less football
knowledge, I think, going around
a lot.
You know you don't see some of
these plays all the time.
Now, part of that is because
guys are playing young.
But the other thing is you're
putting an awful lot of time in
the NFL Like they're not taking
the time to try to build you
completely up as a quarterback,
and I think we've gone to more
and more athletic quarterbacks
where we think, like your feet
are going to be the answer, but
that doesn't always mean that
you have all the other skills
that are behind it, right?
Speaker 2: and that's the
problem when you're in high
school and you're an athletic
quarterback, you can outrun
everybody.
And then when you're in college,
you can outrun, you know, most
of the people, half people and
all of a sudden you get to the
NFL and the third-string
linebacker is chasing you down
and they're like all right, what
do we have to fall back on?
And I think the other thing is
you get these guys who are in
college, who are playing with
superior talent, they look
really good, they get drafted on
the worst team who has nothing,
and then you see a lot of these
situations fail.
And then the worst team who has
nothing, and then you see a lot
of these situations fell.
And then again it's a coach who
knows this team has nothing.
And they're thinking man, I
only have like two to three
years before I get fired.
Let me just throw my guy out
there and hope for the best.
And then, if your team is like,
if there's a disconnect between
your coach and your gm, your
gm's over there building up the
defense to make a run, meanwhile
they've handed you a rookie
quarterback and they've told you
to go ahead and play him the
first year.
It just seems like there's very
few like CJ Stroud-like
situations.
You know what I mean when they
decided to try and build up both
sides and get going, and
there's way more of the other
kind of situations.
Speaker 1: It's really
concerning about guys like
Shador Sanders and Cam Ward that
are going to come out, that are
all mobile, make plays with
their feet If they don't get
developed.
I'm just wondering, because
everybody can't be a Jaden
Daniels.
Those things are really anomaly
.
Greg May was really high in the
draft.
People thought he was going to
be going in the top three in the
draft anyways and he had to sit
behind somebody and it's done
him relatively good, I think.
If he came in and didn't uh,
sit behind brissette for a
little bit, I think it had been
a disaster and we talked about
him in the same light that we
were mac jones.
So I'm like I don't know what
the future for sanders and ward
and guys like that would have
looked like without having some
kind of grooming.
But it's an ongoing
conversation.
I don't know how much time we
have to keep on staying in, so
go ahead real quick with the
comment, then we get into a a
quick uh well, a couple of key
things you hit on there, you so,
like you, you talk about.
Speaker 3: You talk about ward.
His high school ran a wing t.
He had never really thrown the
ball until he got to college,
went to an fcs school, threw the
ball all over the and then has
gone past happy since then.
So it's a guy that had to
develop those skills.
The other thing is you and
Herbert both mentioned we've
talked about Mac Jones before.
You know Mac Jones was throwing
to four top 10 wide receivers
at Alabama.
He got to the Patriots and he
didn't have anyone that would
have receivers at Alabama.
He got to the Patriots and he
didn't have anyone that would
have started at Alabama.
You know you can't discount the
lack of talent when you go up.
The other thing that I wanted
to hit on quickly before we wrap
it up is I don't think people
give Jane Daniels the amount of
credit for the extra work that
he's put in by himself.
Speaker 1: I mean, he's done a
lot of like he's put in by
himself.
Speaker 3: I mean yeah Well.
I mean he he's done a lot of
like.
He's one of the quarterbacks
that jumped on the VR.
Speaker 1: He spends a ton of
time doing that.
Speaker 3: So he's getting reps,
even not physically, but he's.
He's got a chance to see an
awful lot of different defenses
that even he wasn't seeing when
he was at LSU.
I think a lot of credit goes
for his.
He needs to get more credit for
what he does with his brain
than what he's doing just with
his talents, and I don't think a
lot of people have given him
credit for that.
Speaker 1: They sure he's a
smart guy.
Rod said Doreen and Cam are
actually decent pocket passers.
Miro will need some grooming.
What Rod is telling me is that
the Giants shouldn't be drafting
.
Speaker 2: That's what he's
telling me, and I heard you,
roger.
Well, to that point real quick.
If I'm the Giants and you end
up like four to five somewhere
in there, I don't trade up for a
passer and I don't like.
Speaker 1: if it's not Shadur or
Cam, then I just don't get one
in the first round, like at all
I think Correct, that's how
little faith I have in, like
everyone else, and you know,
shannur and Cam both come with
their own.
Speaker 2: you know question
marks as well, so I just think
this is probably one of your
weaker quarterback drafts.
Speaker 1: I don't know whether
this is the answer or not.
And I mean, look at somebody
who I just mentioned, paul
O'Faylor.
He was seventh, he went in the
seventh round.
So it's like I don't know who's
going to be the one.
None of us know, we just
predicting.
So a lot of giants fans,
especially on my twitter, are
talking about ward and sanders,
but you don't see me typing that
.
You know why?
Because I don't know that.
Right, I don't know.
Do we need a quarterback?
I don't know who it's going to
be.
I know free agency is probably
dead to us, but I don't know
that those two guys are going to
be it.
They want them because they
think it's going to be a sure
thing, but I don't know.
I just don't think there is that
can be coached, that can have a
high football IQ Very important
in my book, a high football IQ,
that's what we need.
Let's keep it moving.
As far as last week, real rapid
fire.
Give me one highlight from last
week that kind of stuck out,
blew your mind, shocked you.
One one highlight with some
quick commentary on it.
Then we go into our predictions
and then we hit our uh five
pack poll for the night.
So just one thing that you guys
saw that was uh mind-blowing to
you.
Look at that I meanwise.
Speaker 3: I think there's only
one highlight, and that's Saquon
Barkley.
And I mean, when you watch the
NFL week in and week out and you
see something you've never seen
before, that's when you know
there's some people that are
just built for this.
Speaker 1: Beautiful.
I wasn't going to go ahead, but
since you brought him up, let
me ask you a question honestly
do you feel like this is the
same guy that was playing for
the giants, or is this something
that where he's, or he's doing
something almost almost?
Speaker 2: I don't even know why
you're following that like that
.
Why can't you just appreciate
that play?
That was just an amazing I
don't know, you don't you don't
at.
You just stomped all over his
thing and went into some hate
about the thing you absolutely
did.
You absolutely did.
Speaker 1: No man, I didn't do
that.
What I'm asking is just because
his whole picture.
Everything I'm hearing now is
that this guy is just a world
beater and he was on our team
but he didn't do any good bit of
that, that stuff we had a lot
of problems with as a matter of
fact.
But now he's not only healthy
but he's doing things that are
like amazing.
Am I asking?
I'm asking my question is that
is he doing this?
It's the people point, or this
is who the guy was the whole
time?
Because we've never even seen
some of this stuff.
We've seen some things, but
never anything.
On this level, I'm trying out
what talk to me from you guys
football knowledge what's
different beside the team and
one being bad and the other one
being he's coming out of a Super
Bowl what's different that?
You see, I don't this is
amazing to me.
Speaker 3: I think there's
definitely a level of spite.
I think Saquon Barkley wants to
put it to the Giants.
There's no doubt about that.
Speaker 1: But I also think he's
playing against the light years
.
Speaker 3: better offensive line
, I think, better play calling.
Speaker 1: I think the O-line is
full-sourced.
Speaker 3: Hey, I mean, there's
no doubt that he has a better
offensive line in front of him.
It lets him be able to do what
he needs to do.
I think they get him the ball
in different ways, in which the
Giants didn't always do that,
but I think he's a guy that
likes having a chip on his
shoulder and I think the giants
not thinking that he was up to
his worth and you getting to
stay in your conference and
punish them on the opportunities
you get.
Speaker 1: I think he feeds off
that okay, that's true, I've
been the japanese.
Speaker 2: I also don't think
the Giants should have kept him,
though Like I don't think he
fits.
Speaker 1: It's so much money,
man.
Speaker 2: Yeah, paying for
running back at this point, it's
funny to me that like there's
so much surrounding Saquon
Barkley leaving the Giants and
nothing around Derrick Henry
leaving the Titans.
But, like both teams made the
right decision, both guys needed
to go some rows and they
couldn't afford to pay for
running back.
Given the state of the teams, I
thought it was good for both of
you about the titans, did you?
Speaker 1: yeah, but I think
they're the exact same situation
.
Speaker 2: Both guys are tearing
it up on their new teams,
rightfully so.
Both of their new teams are
better, better built to maximize
their skills, and I I don't see
like that.
The teams that they left made
bad decisions.
Speaker 1: And they may have
their quarterback in the future.
We definitely don't.
So this is we had to do
something, so I don't.
Speaker 2: I don't fault the
Giants at all for letting them
go.
Like it sucks to go to a
division rival.
I get that, yes, but they
couldn't outbid anybody for it.
That wouldn't make sense on
this team.
Speaker 3: No, I agree with you.
I would have tried to get rid
of him before.
I would have traded him when it
was in our power.
Speaker 2: I said that about
Derrick Henry and I love Derrick
Henry, but they should have got
something for him.
Speaker 1: They wanted for him.
I don't know what they thought,
but I don't know what happened.
That was a long one.
You guys froze I don't know if
you're some screen just froze
there for a second but Ben
saying totally agree, I'm not
trading up for anybody but
Shador or Cam right now either.
If you're saying trade up for
Shador or Cam, I don't feel good
about that, I'm sorry.
Speaker 2: I wouldn't trade up
for either one of those two
either, especially if I'm
sitting at like five or six and
they want to haul.
Speaker 1: No, I'm not.
I'm not trying to do that, and
I know you're happy about that.
The news of the week for
Buckley's reverse hurdle was
insane.
That man was joy tested right
after that happened, which is
funny.
How do you do that?
I'm sure you passed.
Regina said mental health
brings a great player out.
I totally agree with that too.
He's maybe the weakest QB class
in a while.
Yeah, it is.
I'm hoping that there's
somebody back there, maybe
somebody that you guys are not
talking about every week.
That's out there for us because
we got to do something.
We can't do.
Juul out for another couple of
years.
We don't, it's not.
We can't wait for Peyton,
little Brother, to come out.
We don't have the time to do
that.
We have to do something ASAP.
Speaker 2: So I don't know what
the answer is for us, but you
might have to wait for that.
You can't reach for a
quarterback in this next draft.
Speaker 1: I don't know, I'm not
suggesting reach, but is there
anybody else that is?
Speaker 2: possible Ewers and
Quinn Ewers, if you believe in
him, with his injury history, or
Carson Beck before he decided
to throw two interceptions a
game.
It's like those are your next
two.
That's it.
I mean Rod mentioned, you know,
but neither one of us would
like Milrow's like a third or
fourth rounder at this point.
Yeah, so I mean.
Speaker 3: I would wait and take
somebody like Rourke at Indiana
.
I think people don't respect
how good of a thrower he has
been.
Both he and his brother at Ohio
tore it up.
His brother tears it up in the
CFL and has gotten some shots on
some teams during the preseason
in the NFL.
But Rourke at Indiana would be
the quarterback.
I'd pick him in the fourth
round and give give him some run
.
I think he's a quarterback
that's going to get the ball out
.
He plays an interesting style
offense so he plays with some
pro style um, but yeah, I I'm
not reaching for anybody in a
quarterback class this year what
shane is saying is if the
giants want to compete in the
cfl, they should draft rourke.
Speaker 2: Otherwise you're
saying something like that.
Speaker 1: I'm like what.
You're talking about giving him
some run.
What do you mean giving him
some run?
You're talking about him
starting.
Speaker 3: Over Drew Locke.
Daniel Tone, your quarterback
is terrible.
Do you have an NFL quarterback
on the Giants right now?
Speaker 1: Drew Locke is an NFL
quarterback.
I just don't like him.
Speaker 2: Yeah, I honestly saw
a universe where they start Drew
Locke for a year Hopefully he's
bad and you pass off for one
more year to get to the high
drop it.
I could see that happening.
Unfortunately, dable gets fired
at the end of this year.
You get off of DJ and you just
let Locke carry the team for a
year, hopefully he's just bad in
the year after you draft a
quarterback.
Speaker 1: These fans will burn
this.
Speaker 2: I'm not saying, look,
if I was a Giants fan I would
absolutely hate it, but from the
outside view I could see this
happening for sure.
Speaker 1: Oh, it's been six
years.
No, sir, it's been like 11
years.
It's been 11 years.
I'm counting.
I know 2022 is an anomaly.
This has been going on for 11
years.
This can't go on another year.
I don't think we can survive it
.
I get it.
John Mayer had to add extra
security to his team.
There's no way in the world.
But any other highlights from
last week that just jumped out?
I want to give a quick shout
out to the Chargers.
Man Herbert, nobody talks about
him.
He's on a hot street.
The man is on fire.
He lit the Browns up.
Now the Browns defense, as bad
as they've been playing in other
areas, their defense has still
been relatively good.
Herbert lit them boys up.
They pressured him, I think 52%
of the time, and he lit them up
for 106 in the score.
When there was no pressure, he
was 11 of 16, 176 yards in the
score.
He was going off on him, and
then Dobbins had two touchdowns
that he ran and they lit him up.
So watch out for the charges
that them boys might be coming.
But, shane, anything that you
saw was a highlight beside what
we talked about already.
If not, we'll move on to our
predictions for this week.
Speaker 3: I think the two you
mentioned are pretty forward in
my mind.
Can I give a shout-out?
Speaker 2: to the Bills-Dolphins
game then Because that was a
fun one.
That was a really good one.
Speaker 1: Ben Parker said it's
a great year to draft a
quarterback outside the first
round.
Even though I like Shador and
Cam, no, we couldn't tell they
don't look as impressive as the
top quarterbacks from the past
couple of years.
They don't.
Speaker 2: Shador comes with the
Sanders baggage, and Cam Ward,
like once a game, throws the
most inexplicable interception,
you know, going out of bounds on
the right, throwing back into
the middle of the field, you
know.
And then he's got several other
highlights, but I agree with
him.
I would do my homework on other
guys, just like with shane
mentioned.
Yeah, you know, find yourself a
gym and have to be locked and
say you're in a perfect position
.
All right, drew lock's gonna
start and we're gonna I don't
know, I don't even know that
much I don't know.
Speaker 3: I mean it's.
It's either that, or you call
Atlanta and go hey, has our
year's plan changed?
Now that you're doing okay, you
know, do you try for Michael
Panics now?
Do you make a move for Bryce
Young?
Do you go after some of these
younger guys that maybe teams
have given up on and maybe you
have a shot at?
I don't think Atlanta thought
that it was going to go as well
as it's going right now.
I thought they'd be able to get
some wins out of it.
But maybe I ring the bell and
find out what they need to get
Penix off of their books.
Speaker 1: Penix is not going.
You know good and well.
They didn't go up to eight last
year to get rid of him and
trade him somewhere.
Speaker 3: Cousins will go
before he goes, I'd make a call.
I'd make a call.
Speaker 1: You know better.
That's not going to happen.
I don't think the Giants are
going to try.
What do you guys think about?
Speaker 2: Neusmeier oh, I
forgot about him.
I don't like him Enough to
where I forgot about him.
Oh well, next topic how about
this?
I will tell you more next week
about him, because we're about
to get an up-close-and-personal
look at him.
Speaker 1: All right.
So I talked about Drew Allen on
this show many times, but I'm
not seeing it.
He got the size and he got the
arm and I'm sure coaches will
like him, but oh man, what I've
seen I just don't.
Do you guys like him, even in
the context of our team and what
we would need as a total
typical quarterback?
Do you like him?
Sorry, man, I'm glad I'm not
insane by even thinking about it
.
All right, so predictions for
next week.
You know how we do it.
How did we do last week?
I think I did pretty good last
week.
I keep tracking the numbers.
I keep tracking how we're doing
.
I don't want that job.
It's too much work.
Speaker 2: I nominate Shane.
Speaker 1: Shane said he'll do
it.
If you're down with Shane, by
all means, the job is yours.
With me I can start.
If we need that, ok, please do.
So.
We can kind of just have a
number for how we're doing.
So we can just, you know,
either feel good about ourselves
or see how we can change.
Speaker 2: I feel bad enough
about myself on a daily basis.
Speaker 1: It could be
encouraging to you.
Who knows?
All right, so the Giants are
going to Munich to play the
Panthers.
Now everybody's saying we
should be losing this game, we
should be continuing the tanking
.
Speaker 3: Yes, you should.
Speaker 1: No, am I Giants?
Then go out here and stop
mordor-holding the Panthers.
But I'm going to go ahead
Because I don't trust them.
I'm going to pick the Panthers,
believe it or not.
I'm like, yeah, I got to trust
the shoes, hashtag, trust the
year right now.
Speaker 2: So I'm picking the
Panthers, how you guys going
Giants Panthers in Munich 9.30
on Sunday morning.
I'll go Panthers.
Speaker 3: I'm going Giants, but
they should lose.
They should lose, yeah.
Speaker 2: I had to pull up my
pick on me.
I took the Panthers.
Oh, you did Okay.
Speaker 1: Perfect to see his
college picks every week.
He's got enough, I have to see.
Speaker 2: Ho's college picks.
I know some Ho's that he has to
do his college picks.
Speaker 1: Oh boy, I'm going to
go ahead and step up.
I don't know, I got people, we
got a little kid there.
Speaker 2: Mike, shame on you,
Mike.
Speaker 1: Can you see me at
church?
What did he mean by Ho, mr
Yous't even see me at church.
What did he mean by a hose, mr
Houston, I don't want that in my
life, okay, thanks, mike Bad
Mike Pass at Bears.
Bears at home.
I go Bears Just because I don't
know any better.
I go Bears, of course that's
just cool.
But they don't know any better,
I go Bears, of course that's
just cool.
Speaker 2: But they don't even
want to win Like.
This is a game that the Pats
should not be trying to win.
Speaker 3: And what have I just
done?
I picked the Giants who should
want to lose and the Patriots
who should want to lose.
Speaker 2: Oh Wow.
Speaker 1: This is getting super
personal.
Speaker 2: It's interesting that
Mike started off trying to make
fun of me and now he wants
sympathy.
How's that working out for you,
mike?
Speaker 1: what I didn't see was
an asterisk with the correction
.
Speaker 2: Now we make a mistake
that's because there was no
mistake.
Speaker 1: I don't see any
comments.
So think about that pal.
All right, all right.
Bills at Colts.
I'm going Bills here.
The Bills probably going to
start my mud hole in them
whether Flacco's playing or not.
So I'm going Bills here.
You guys feel the same way.
Bills across the board.
Easily.
Vikes at Jaguars, come, come on
.
Yeah, donald's gonna throw a
touch up interception, but
they're still gonna beat the
brakes on the jaguars.
Agreed, agreed.
Copy that.
Broncos at sheeps.
I'm appalled because it's not.
This is one of those games that
it could be the one, but I'm
going cheap.
Speaker 2: Sit on, yeah, but I
don't like oh you reminded me of
what my biggest takeaway if
you're're on the road playing
the champ, you go for two Like I
don't even understand these
terrible decisions.
That's what I was wanting to
say.
Sorry, I know it's the wrong
time, but that was my biggest
takeaway.
I don't see how you even decide
like.
I could do a whole hour on how
bad a decision that was, but
that was terrible.
Speaker 1: I don't even know
myself.
The Chiefs man, this is the
poker.
Are the Chiefs for real, these
games that we've seen?
I don't see it Undefeated.
It looks like they try
sometimes.
Speaker 2: Well, you see how
teams are just scared into
making terrible decisions.
Hey, we're a good running team.
Let's not run the ball.
Hey, we've just scored.
There's under a minute left.
Let's not go to two.
Let's take Patrick Mahomes to
overtime.
Okay, great idea guys.
Speaker 1: I know I made my
girlfriend Regina mad, but I'm
sorry, regina.
They don't look good.
They're undefeated but they
don't look good.
I don't get it.
Okay, I'm going cheese against
the Broncos.
I don't expect a big scoring
differential between them.
I think it's going to be a lot
closer.
Especially if Nick gets the
ball out of his hands quickly, I
think they'll have a closer
game than what we might think.
Falcons at Saints they don't
have a lot of ball.
Just in case you were wondering
, he's not on their team anymore
.
I'm going to Falcons here.
Shane same here.
All right.
Niners at Buccaneers this is a
tight one.
I don't know the answer to this
.
I just saw something on my
notifications pop up that it
said something.
I didn't see what it said, so I
was trying not to pay attention
to it while I was on the show.
He should be expected to return
against the Bucks in this game.
Jordan Mason is still
questionable.
Between him and Garendo, I
think McAfee is going to get his
opportunity to eat and Jordan
Mason is still questionable.
So between him and Guarindo, I
think McCaffrey's going to get
his opportunity to eat.
So I'm going to go with the
Niners here, but I'm going,
niners.
Speaker 3: Shane.
I like Niners, but the Bucs
offensively are always going to
keep them in games.
Speaker 2: Yeah, yeah.
And then their defense will
keep them right back out of the
game.
And I said I you know how I do,
I listen to anybody who's lost
a tough one, their podcast and
his defender, the, the tepabay
guy, is just like he's mad at
the decision and he's mad at the
defense.
Like defense, just horrible.
Like is anybody even out there
on the field at times.
Speaker 1: So yeah, all right,
here's a good one.
Now, steelers at Commanders.
I'll be honest, man, I'm not
sure, but you guys?
Well, first, I really don't
know the answer.
Do you guys have one, because I
have to need some more time to
think about.
Speaker 2: I'm picking
Pittsburgh, but this will be.
I mean, the styles are
interesting.
You know he's kind of got
strength on strength for sure.
Um, does mike williams become
the x factor in this one?
Is he up to speed already?
Which feels like the pittsburgh
playbook for an should be like
two pages.
Speaker 3: So I don't even know
it's a post-it note run right,
waggle pass yeah.
Speaker 2: So I'm taking
Pittsburgh, but I think that'll
be it.
Speaker 3: Enjoy that game All
right, how about you Sam?
Speaker 2: Ben Parker.
Speaker 3: I'm going with the
Commanders.
Speaker 2: I like that pick.
Speaker 3: I think this is a
time for them to, you know,
prove that they're an upper
echelelon team.
I think they've won some games
uh, they don't have one that
really sticks out.
I think if you beat a solid
pittsburgh defense, I think that
this could be one that really
puts them up wow, but I guess
it's my time and I still don't
know I'm gonna command this at
home.
Speaker 1: I don't.
Speaker 2: I think that's a good
pick.
That's probably the smarter
pick for sure you know what.
Speaker 1: That's probably
what's not going to happen too.
I got a feeling in my gut that
this is going to pull it out,
but I'm like I don't have any
numbers.
I don't have any numbers, I
don't know what the odds were,
but I just got a feeling, man,
it's still going to pull it out
I.
But I don't feel great about it
whatsoever, just to be honest.
Speaker 2: Can I mention Carson
Beck?
The only person on this list is
not a pro, catching just a
random straight.
Speaker 1: Yeah, I want to see
how he got broken through, big
neck got thrown into the sea and
Carson Beck got pulled out.
How did that happen?
I don't know where we'll be
going with that one.
That's funny, though, dang man.
I think that Chargers I'm going
Chargers here pretty easily.
I don't have any doubt.
That's what's going to happen.
You guys got Chargers or Titans
.
Speaker 2: Chargers, oh Chargers
.
Speaker 1: Yeah, all right, this
is a tough one too.
Jets at Cardinals.
I'm going with Cardinals
because you know.
Cardinals I don't care, even
Rodgers leads, I'm still saying
the same thing.
I'm picking on Jets on this
squad, eagles at Cowboys.
Speaker 2: Cowboys losing at
home.
Speaker 1: Now Mingo might be
the X-Factor in this game,
though you know he ain't going
to be the X-Factor in nothing,
I'm just saying so.
Do you know there's a?
Speaker 2: conspiracy theory
that Jerry Jones traded for
Mingo to take to be a
distraction so nobody would be
talking about.
Like how bad they are and the
Dak Prescott injury they had
better options.
Speaker 1: They wanted to really
really get somebody who was
like what a bigger distraction.
A name that you actually know
they're out there.
Jonathan Mingo was not the one
that you would have been
thinking of, so no, jerry Jones
is just trying to find somebody
to play with Trey Lance.
That's all he's doing right now
.
Lions at Texas.
I'm going Lions here.
Yeah, going Lions.
Speaker 2: Texas is dope like.
Are they in a softball slump or
is it just the injuries or just
?
Speaker 1: no, I gave you props
on Twitter about that.
You called it, man, a
regression in CJ Stroud.
You called it in the beginning
of the well in the offseason.
That's exactly what's happening
.
He's regressed Facts.
Now, ben, stop it.
Ben, if you have a fantasy team
and you put Mingo on your team
and you start him, you get what
you pay for, all right.
Speaker 2: I feel like someone
here must be playing against ben
this weekend because it feels
kind of it just kind of weighted
in person it's a setup.
Speaker 3: I'll tell you what,
though.
Ben has been bringing out these
mystery questions on his
podcast and uh, austin and I
knew that dallas was terrible,
but this last one was about the
defense in the nfl and the.
The basic answer is that dallas
is terrible at everything.
Like.
As much as you may think
they're bad, you don't even have
the team's understanding of how
bad dallas's defense is.
So you know anybody playing
against dallas.
I'm gonna pick them on my
fantasy team.
Speaker 1: Yeah, that's actually
good, I ain't putting them on
my team Catching them at a food
dinner Homemade mac and cheese
included while listening to
y'all.
Thanks for the entertainment,
no problem.
Speaker 3: Gotta help out a
Saints fan.
Speaker 1: That's a good thing,
right, that we help.
Okay, I'm not quite sure where
to go with that.
It's good, Thank you.
All right, last game Dolphins
at Rams.
I can't pick the Dolphins here,
I'm sorry.
I don't think that they've
gotten back to their normal form
yet.
So I'm going Rams here,
especially if Pacquiao he only
got kicked out of the last game,
he should be back in this game.
They didn't look good in that
last game at all.
But you guys got numbers on the
Rams-Dolphins game.
Speaker 2: I went.
I did go Dolphins in support of
Raj.
Speaker 1: That's fine.
I'm sure he'll appreciate that.
Speaker 2: He might talk bad
about me somehow or blame me for
them losing.
Speaker 1: I got Rams here, so
I'm not going to even mess
around with this.
Speaker 2: And Raj posted
earlier that the Dolphins were
going to lose on Monday night.
He did, yeah.
Speaker 1: Yeah, but I don't
know if he was serious.
Was it LOL after it?
Or he was just okay, no, LOL,
he meant everything he said no,
that's a statement.
Speaker 2: And we didn't pick
tonight's game, did we?
Speaker 1: Holy smokes.
No, okay, all right, so Holy
smokes, no, okay, all right.
Speaker 2: So we got a holy
smokes out of it.
I like it.
Speaker 1: This is funny.
Okay, this is funny Cause I
this is another tough one Cause
you look at the record and you
think, oh, it's easy, we're
going to go mop the floor with
him.
No, no, I don't.
I don't know.
I don't know that because I
have Gusecki and Brown going, I
need them to go off and go crazy
out here.
So I'm going to do something
crazy I'm going to pick the
Bengals.
Speaker 2: I don't even think
that's crazy to be honest you
don't.
They had the first game won.
They basically gave that one
away.
Like I am picking the Ravens,
but I think your pick is valid.
It's probably more well thought
out, honestly, than my pick.
Like I said, they had the first
one won.
Their offense has actually been
playing well lately.
They need to go on a run.
What if the Ravens decide to
Raven?
You never know with them this
could be the game where they
decide to throw 50 times.
Speaker 1: Have they got the
minus six?
Speaker 2: I would never.
If I was that kind of person,
it would be Bengals plus six,
all day.
Speaker 1: Hmm, no, they got the
Ravens minus six.
That makes sense, but I'm still
going with the Bengals, all
right.
So, shane, you got all of these
picks.
Man, you got them all locked in
.
Speaker 2: Shane hasn't made his
pick.
Speaker 1: I'm going.
Speaker 2: Ravens.
Speaker 1: Okay, that makes
sense, all right, so we got time
for our five-pack poll, ready
for it.
Oh shoot, I'm going to send you
right here so we can watch a
little TNF.
I'm excited about this game
tonight.
This should be a good one.
All right, but let's go ahead
and jump in.
This is fun, man.
Good show today, by the way,
guys.
Awesome stuff so far.
Thank you guys for listening
and watching and commenting.
Great job by you, great
questions and comments.
We love it.
Please keep that coming and
please share us on your social
media platforms.
Thank you for doing that in
advance.
All right, so our five-pack poll
goes like this every week and
hopefully we can keep this going
.
I'm going to need you guys to
help After Thanksgiving it.
You guys help, uh, after
thanksgiving kind of helped me
organize some of the stuff again
.
But every week we get five
teams in five categories.
First category win the division
.
Second category last place in
the division.
Third category playing in the
super bowl.
Not winning it, but playing in
the super bowl within the next
three years.
The fourth one is a full
rebuild and the fifth one is a
first round, first round playoff
exit.
Our five teams this week are the
Los Angeles Chargers, the
Pittsburgh Steelers, the Houston
Texans, the Minneapolis Vikings
and the Atlanta Falcons.
So the Chargers, the Steelers,
the Texans, the Vikings and the
Falcons, all of these teams have
something in common they're all
contending for the playoffs, so
right now they're in a great
position to get there.
I think the Chargers should be
included in that.
If my math is correct, they
should be in contention for a
playoff berth.
And thank you, ben.
We love the 5-5 team.
We love you too, brother.
Thank you, man, it's awesome.
So how do you guys want me to
start off?
Do?
Speaker 2: you guys have some
time, or are?
Speaker 1: you guys ready to
roll?
I'm stuck on one part.
All right, shane, you ready for
me to go?
Speaker 3: You can start.
I'm ready to go, but I'll let
you lead.
Speaker 1: Copy that, copy that,
all right.
So for first-round playoff exit
, I'm going Texans here.
I could have put them in a
couple of spots, but I'm putting
them here.
Herb called it in the offseason
definitely regression and
they're in a weak division,
which doesn't help.
They got three or four teams
that are looking at major
overhauls so they kind of had a
false sense of security and the
stars that are kind of
difference makers that are not
playing digs us out for the
season.
Nico should be back sometime
soon, but I think it's gonna be
maybe a little longer than we
thought, so maybe going into
december or later.
So I think if there's a first
round playoff exit in this group
, it's them full rebuild.
Believe it or not.
I'm going with the pittsburgh
steelers here.
I never have a long-term
quarterback yet and I know that
russell's doing good.
But you know it's one thing to
be good and they got tape on you
the year after.
We know how that looks.
So it's a little bit different
and I don't know if field's
gonna be coming back.
If russell stays, I doubt
field's coming back and if
russell leaves, field would be
the guy.
So I don't know what they plan
to do there.
But it's a good chance they got
something to do with the
quarterback quarterback at least
in the next couple years.
They they got Pickens, who is
his contract, up after next year
, cordero Patterson up after
next year, najee up after this
year, fields up after this year
and Daniels, their starting
guard, up after this year.
So they got a lot of people to
pay, a lot of mouths to feed.
I don't see them paying
everybody Playing the Super Bowl
in the next three years.
I'm going with the Chargers here
.
They're building the
championship team the way I
enjoy.
I've seen it in the national
championship game.
I saw how they built that team
and I like the pattern they used
to build a team on defense and
with the running game, and the
Chargers have done that and
they're doing that in great
display.
In the past two or three games
I think it was so they beat them
in the last place in the
division, believe it or not.
I'm going with the Vikings here.
You know why?
Because out of all the guys in
this five-pack, this is the only
team in this group that's about
two games from last place.
Everybody was four games from
last place, five games from last
place.
The Vikings are two games out.
As good as they're playing.
Then they got seven wins.
They're two games out from last
place and they had some trouble
in play from darnell recently
relying on uh they running back
who's injured a lot of the time.
I love me some aaron jones man,
don't get me wrong, but he
burned me in fantasy for many a
year.
He gave me a thousand yards and
that man will go out and I'll
be dead in the water, dead duck.
So I'm going with the Minnesota
Vikings and of course that
leads to Atlanta Falcons as the
division winners.
What you got, shane.
Speaker 3: So I am very close to
you, Yusuf.
Speaker 2: You gave me the final
piece of my puzzle there.
Speaker 3: So I went Houston as
the division winner.
I think we've talked about them
already.
Um, for me, for the dead last,
I went the vikings as well, not
because I think that they're
going to be terrible, but
because that's a tough, uh
division for them.
You know you, you can easily
come in last and still have a
winning record right now.
I mean that that group right
there is tough to beat.
I went with the Chargers as
well.
I'm probably not as big of a
Harbaugh guy as you are, but I
have always thought that he does
a great job in leading his
teams.
He gets the most out of his
guys, and I think the Chargers
have some components.
They need some more weapons on
offense, but they have a good
offensive line some run game.
The defense is playing
outstanding this year.
Um, for that, pittsburgh again,
I think you hit on all the key
points.
I don't think they've made a
decision on a quarterback.
And the other thing is for
pittsburgh at some point you're
gonna run out of magic, you're
gonna fall down on a bad season
and I think if pittsburgh gets
to where they have a bad season,
they're're not going to want
that to happen again and they'll
try to rebuild as quickly as
possible.
And then for me, for the
first-round exit, I went with
the Falcons.
I think they have the talent,
but I also wouldn't be surprised
to see them lose an early-round
game.
Speaker 1: Yeah, if Cousins is
the quarterback, yeah, that
could happen.
Yep, herbo, what you?
That could happen.
Yeah, her role with your
brother.
Speaker 2: Yeah, I mean you guys
hit on the easiest one for me
Pittsburgh and the rebuild.
And that's like I like them, I
like Tomlin.
But you know, you all know my
rule If you don't have a
quarterback situation set up for
the future, you go into my
rebuild category.
So that's where I'm going to be
Houston Super Bowl in three
years, just because I'd love to
see it.
I'd love to meet O'Ryans over
there, Will Anderson's there as
well, so that would be mine.
So then the rest of them kind
of slotted in First round exit
with the Chargers.
That gave me Atlanta first in
their division.
That one actually kind of
seemed easy with the division
falling apart around them.
And then so that's what I
couldn't figure out is who I
would have last, because
originally I had Atlanta, but I
was like if Carolina exists, I
could never get to that point,
like in this season or like any
other season.
So the Minnesota.
I like the logic on Minnesota,
just because of how their
division is.
You don't have to be bad to
finish last in their division.
Yeah, that's a good point.
Yeah Well.
Speaker 1: I stole your point.
Speaker 2: So good point for you
.
If you see all the scribbles on
my paper, I'm like this was a
good one because, like you said,
they weren't contending
contenders.
So it worked out really well.
Speaker 1: This is good man.
This was some good stuff, man.
I had fun with this.
We're just going to spend a
little bit more time on a couple
of topics, but you know what?
It's all good, we had a good
time.
If I'm not mistaken, Herb's
going to be out next week.
He's going to be doing some two
weeks For the next two weeks.
Fair enough.
Speaker 2: No, no, no, I mean
like not next week.
In two weeks I will be gone.
I will be flying out to Dallas
for the Oklahoma game.
Speaker 1: That's what the
problem is.
The 21st I will be gone Because
I'm going to the Oklahoma game.
You just scratched everything I
said.
I don't know what I'm talking
about, I don't know today's date
and you told me what to say.
But whatever, right.
But wherever you are and happy
you're hearing our show, thanks
again for listening and making
us a part of your week.
We are out of here.
Have fun, guys.
I love all the comments.
Oh man, we missed, spent some
time and making us a part of
your week.
We are out of here.
Have fun, guys.
Love all the comments.
Oh man, we missed some time
with you, brother.
We're out of here now.
Speaker 2: We're about to bounce
.
Now he's got a show that comes
on at the same time.
Speaker 1: That's why yeah, I
know, man, we go on to OT.
Next time you have some more
time to come and join us, man.
We hear your thoughts on George
and some other stuff, man.
But thanks again for joining us
, everybody for the comments and
the questions.
We love it.
If you support, we are out of
here and I got to find the music
so I can play it.
And we out, we out, we out.