They Call Me Mista Yu
← All episodes

She Built a $6 Million Online Business Her Own Way: Trusting Yourself, Building Community & Starting Again at 65 | Carol Tice

26:53

Have a question or thought for Mista Yu? Text or leave a voicemail for the show and he’ll answer it personally on the Inspiration Station or They Call Me Mista Yu. With your Permission, We'll even play your message live on the air!

What if you're not too old, too late, or too unconventional to build something remarkable?

In this episode of They Call Me Mista Yu, I sit down with Carol Tice, a longtime journalist, book ghostwriter, online-business pioneer, and entrepreneur who has spent more than a decade proving that there isn't only one way to build a successful business.

After struggling to make a living as a writing coach and blogger, Carol founded the Freelance Writers Den in 2011.

What started as a paid community eventually grew to more than 1,500 paying members and generated nearly $6 million over the life of the business. It replaced her husband's income, supported their family for more than a decade, and ultimately became a business she was able to sell for life-changing money.

But Carol's entrepreneurial story didn't end with the sale.

At 65, she started again.

Her new venture, The 90 Day Community Relaunch, teaches coaches, consultants, and experts how to build profitable paid communities that can create recurring revenue, meaningful impact, and potentially a more valuable business asset.

In this conversation, we explore:

  • How Carol turned a struggling career into a $6 million business
  • Why she chose the paid-community model
  • What makes an online community commercially viable
  • When a paid community isn't the right business model
  • Building a business that doesn't depend entirely on its founder
  • The difference between income and enterprise value
  • How to create a business that can eventually be sold
  • Overcoming fear, ageism, and revenue plateaus
  • Knowing when to persist and when to pivot
  • Starting a new business at 65
  • Building a business around your strengths instead of conventional wisdom
  • How coaches and consultants can create recurring revenue
  • Why you don't necessarily need a large audience to launch
  • Building an online business without being highly technical
  • What it means to trust yourself enough to build your own way

Carol's story isn't simply about making money online.

It's about refusing to let conventional wisdom determine what your business—or your life—is supposed to look like.

And perhaps the biggest lesson is this:

You're not finished just because you've already succeeded. And you're not too late because you haven't started yet.

Support the show

In this episode

Read the transcript
SPEAKER_00: What if the conventional path to building a successful business is actually the thing keeping you from building the business that's right for you? Today's guest is a longtime journalist, book ghostwriter, online business pioneer, and founder. She's a Renaissance woman. Just put it out there. She turned a struggling writing career into something much bigger. Build a six million dollar online business and had the courage to start on a new journey of discovery at age 65. Let's welcome Carol Tice to the show. Thanks for joining us on the flightship, Carol. How are you? SPEAKER_01: I am doing good and happy to be here. SPEAKER_00: Same here, same here. Well, you got a lot of stuff to be uh to uh share with us about. So I want to get into some of those things right now, but let's talk a little bit about what you have uh kind of a your journey from, I guess, in your words, struggling to six million dollars. I feel like that's the kind of thing that anybody that's watching, listen to our show, it's like, okay, leave with that. So I said, I'm gonna go ahead and leave with it. You went from struggling to six million dollars. Take us back to 2011. What happened there? SPEAKER_01: Okay, so what had happened was I was I had done 12 years as a staff writer. I was back to freelancing and I after getting fired, by the way. And I, you know, it went right into that 08, 09, 10 downturn. And I was like, well, okay, about that. I need to grow my business. And I grew it from about 50, 60k a year to 100K during that downturn. And as I talked to other writers, I was hearing a lot of I'm starving, there's no work, I'm writing articles for$5. And I was like, I don't get that. Why is that happening to you? You're you know, you're such a tiny business that you get that the giant micro macroeconomic factors don't have to like impact you. There's still room for your tiny little hundred K business, you know, in it. But they didn't, and they weren't marketing. And so I started a blog, is where it began, make a living writing. And eventually at looking for a way to monetize that blog, that became the community. I joined a paid community on how to be a better blogger and went, ooh, I love this model, paid community. This is awesome. I'm learning a lot. And I sat on that for a while and then went to a conference, an online business conference, and came home really fired up, did a 90-day lunch, and got it up finally. And so I had my audience from my blog, and it just built from there, built to 500 members pretty quickly, and then we closed the doors and stopped being open all the time, and it built to a thousand, and then we were stuck there for a while, and then I started getting approached about selling it. And I learned the first time that happened, I was like, no, that's crazy talk. I love my magical cash machine of the internet, you know. Why would I ever get rid of this? And then, you know, time goes by and children graduate, and you're thinking about a new phase of your life. And about the third time somebody asked me, I was like, Well, what would the next step be? And they were like, Well, we send over a term sheet. And I said, We'll send it over. Let me see what's on it. And what I learned is to make an exit, I would want, I needed to grow the business 50% more. And I actually hired a business consultant and did that, grew it to 1,500 members, and then I sold it. So the six million, I just want to clarify, that's like lifetime of the business across the decade. And this was all back before AI, and I had a staff of 10, and it's not like I'm sitting around on a mega yacht and I have six million dollars in my pocket. That's not what happened, but I did get a nice exit that allowed us to, you know, buy our RV for cash and fix up the house and then sell it. And then we were full-time for two years in the RV, just doing a lot of travel, love and life. And and I thought I was done with community, and I was just ghostwriting books for thought leaders, you know, back to my own freelancing. But then I got sucked back in to the new and much easier and more beautiful world of community that exists today, which is that there are platforms that enable community like school and circle and kidabi. And there's now, you know, platforms that make it super easy and cheap to be in the community business. And so community is just exploding. And now I teach the community model. You know, I had a decade as an owner operator and had an exit, which very few small business owners do. So I I kind of jumped back in and I'm kind of loving it. I love the school ecosystem. It's an amazing place to meet other entrepreneurs and collaborate and grow your membership just by I mostly promote my communities on school. SPEAKER_00: I love it. So tell Michael. So, what what about a paid community makes you believe it can become a viable business? What has to happen? I know a lot of friends who may be watching this or listening later on on replay that either they desire to or they have started a paid community. What makes that what's what makes the next step of that, I should say, a viable business, a viable company? How's that work? SPEAKER_01: That is an epic question, Mr. U, because now that it's easy to start communities, people are starting them. They are starting them without building an audience ahead of their launch, without any i market research into how they will be different, what is already in my competitive space, who else is in my industry and what are they doing, and how could I be different? And then they have eight members, and then they are sad because that is not gonna be enough action for community. So, community is a little bit of a you know magical, mystical thing because you are building it, but it won't be a business, it won't be a viable business unless you get something like a hundred people in it fairly quickly. You need enough people where it people come in and it feels like a community. There's stuff going on, people are talking, there's conversations, you're having events. You know, there has to be that feeling of peer support. People come to communities for the peer journey, or they could just go on teachable and take a class from you, you know, uh at that in their own bubble by themselves. But a lot of people suck at executing all by themselves. And that's why community is like the business model for the future is we are all lonely, we all know about this bowling alone, you know, that that everyone is disconnected and looking at their phones and feeling very depressed. And what they need is people who get them, uh people who get what they're going through. I'm vegan and I need to learn more about vegan recipes. And oh, you have a vegan community. I joined one yesterday, is just why I toss out that example. I was like, ooh. So the school news, I think, mentioned them or something, and I was like, oh, I should, I'm always looking for more, you know, great recipes. Why am I not in there? And I go in there and I'm like, oh, this is great. You know, that finding affinity with other people is super powerful. And the great thing about it is you're building a business that doesn't all depend on you. Yeah, you are creating something that if you do it right, almost doesn't need you. You know, you're like occasionally giving it a little poke and and the community is going, you know, and they're requesting things, and you're going, oh, okay, I'll make that, you know, and they're talking amongst themselves and they're getting accountability buddies that they call every week, and they're they're using that model to accelerate their own success or their journey to lose weight or meet someone or whatever they're doing, you know, whatever the community's about. And that's why it's so beautiful because we are all tired of being sold by faceless corporations who want to hand you something, and that's the whole relationship. You know, it's like, okay, I delivered your thing, bye. You know, people are looking for connection, they're looking for relationships. And the thing about the community model is that it allows you to have a broad impact. And this was a big thing for me because I didn't just want to teach a few people, you know, I had done one-on-one coaching, I had done small group coaching for writers, and it was better than the one-on-one coaching. It was more effective because they had, you know, 10 of them. And community to me was the logical next step was to multiply that impact. And there's there's just a reality that this model allows you to use the power of mass adoption to drive your price to nothing, to really low. You know, I'm gonna charge you $1,000 or$5,000 or$10,000 to do a coaching package with you. But for$25 a month, no obligation, leave anytime. I was able to help$14,000 people and make a good living. And that was important to me because I I actually wanted to move the needle of my whole industry. I wanted to influence the entire conversation around the value of freelance writers, what they should charge, what your your work is worth, and to help people understand that you know they didn't have to write for content medals for$10 an article, and that there were good clients and how to get them. And I couldn't do that one-on-one coaching a dozen people a year. I could never have that impact. And to me, it was just the most beautiful thing ever to be able to have people for$25 a month having an all-you-can-eat library of resources on how to market their business, write high-paying kinds of writing, and have that bigger impact. So that's why I love this business model. Is it's multiple advantages for both you as the owner and for the participants. They are getting a fortune's worth of value on the cheap. And because it's cheap, you can attract enough people that it's still a very serious income for you. SPEAKER_00: So I want to come, I want to come back to that. I want to ask your question first. I want to come back to the whole paid community model idea and the one-on-one coaching because I've had experience in both. I'm curious about something I want to ask you about. But before we do that, I I want to commend you first on having the courage to do business your own way. It seems as though a constant thread in your story that you buck conventional wisdom when it comes to the traditional path of entrepreneurship. Carol, what do you have to unlearn? What did you have to unlearn about how a business is supposed to be built, you know, to create the business that actually worked for you? Which is about an unlearned mindset or uh an approach. SPEAKER_01: Well, to kick it off, you know, you're supposed to be young when you start a business. There's actually a lot of data that all the great, you know, Nobel-winning discoveries, all of the breakthrough business startups, somebody was in their 20s or 30s. And that after that, it's like a real big downslope, uh, and nobody, you know, I guess has that inner freedom and courage, and you know, that of the the hubris of youth to like do it. And I started the first one when I was like, I think nearly 50. So I guess the first step was ignoring, you know, that. Oh, this is a game for the young, blah, blah, blah. I seem to be missing a gene that a lot of people have where they're afraid to put themselves out there, they're afraid to experiment, they're afraid to try different things. And I just don't care. And I'd like to encourage everyone listening to this to whatever you're hearing the gurus saying out there, if it doesn't resonate for you, just go, I don't care. That that's not me. That's not for me. You know, on school, they have a whole thing where you should be grinding 24-7 to get a flame. If you do 30 days of continuous action on school, you get a flame by your name, and people think you're hot something. That could, oh, you're really in on school. You're all in on school, you're doing this. I have never had a flame. I take, I am a Sabbath keeper. I am never on on my Saturdays. And that is how I was able to sustainably help, you know, 1,500 needy writer, neurotic children at a time for 10 years because it was sustainable, because I was not burning myself out always doing it. So that I rejected the hustle culture kind of thing right off the bat. What are other things I refuse to do? Well, you know, every girl will tell you that when you have a low-ticket offer, Mr. U, what you need is upsells. You need a high-ticket offer, you need a$10,000 offer, or you're just gonna be nobody. I've never had one. I have never had a really, a truly high-ticket offer. I think as high as I went was like I had a coaching program, a small group coaching program for mid-career writers that was like maybe$1,200. SPEAKER_00: I gotta, I gotta jump in, I gotta jump in here because you you you you leave you leaving me far behind. And I'm like, I I need you to stay here just for a moment. This is where I need you right now. Okay. A couple more questions in the show, but I have to ask this two-part question before we get to the final shirt question of our show. So I gotta ask this now. You talked about the paid community model, and and you explained it very clearly how it worked for you. I've been in school, I've been in some things like that, and the results were a little bit different for me. It wasn't my model, it wasn't my school, but it didn't work out for me the way it did for you, which is fine. No, no, no shade being thrown at all. I've been a coach for I'm in year 30 now. So I've done the one-on-one thing. So I need to ask you two questions, and you be helping me out. So, this is probably the most selfish thing I've done on my show in in ever in ever. You helping me out. This is about me, right now. All right, so the first part of my two-part question. Let me reword that, let me rephrase that. Okay, so in the coaching consulting space, you mentioned coaching, so I don't understand what you meant by that. You never had to do a high-ticket offer. So, I guess my question is is there ever a situation where a paid community is the wrong business model? That's one part of my question. And two, if you were giving advice to somebody who is generally high performance coaching, life coaching, business coaching, whatever, how is a paid community model uh built out or running the way you've been running it? How does that work for them? Because most times we we've been force-fed this, Carol. You gotta have uh a multi-tiered offer, you gotta have a you know uh four different tiers. And I find it nauseating. Maybe it's just me. But how do I, as a coach, have a community like that where I don't have those things? And and then the second part of the question is when's the paid community not the right business model, depending on what genre or whatever. SPEAKER_01: So well, let me start with that. So paid community or free community is not the model for you if you don't have a big heart and a passion for helping your people. Because if you would like to just drop something on people and go, you're socially anxious and you don't want to make friends with people, you know, whatever. This isn't your mode of doing business, where you really want to come alongside people and be with people for years and hang out with them, and you kind of don't enjoy socializing with your people, then yeah, this is not gonna work out because they do want some of you, you know, they're partly here for the you. You don't want it to be too much you, or it's not a saleable asset. So that's you know, the other side of my thought process, having cleaned up the sale and taken myself out of the business to sell it, is that I'd like everyone to have that in the back of their mind, although it shouldn't be too much you. But it can be, it can have upsells. And there's people who are doing just free communities and then they upsell all their courses out of it, but the membership is free. There's a lot of models now, so that's one. They there are communities where the membership is$2,500 a year, $5,000 a year, and it's essentially them selling their premium program, and they're only taking 10 people at a time, and then they're closing the doors. Or so you can run the community model these days. I mean, I don't know about other platforms, but school makes this super easy and you super easy to change your mind. I just changed my pricing. I eliminated my free level and went to one week trial and it rolls into paid membership instead. I'm playing with that now. So it depends on what it is you're building, you know, and what you deliver and who your ideal client is and what their budget is. My people were broke freelance writers, and I knew that about them. And not only were they broke, but even if they weren't broke, they had a poverty mentality. They're that starving artist mentality. And I would hear these people be like, you need a$5,000 offer. And I was like, I'm telling you right now, my people are not paying$5,000 for this. No, you know, so you can bang your head against a wall trying to follow like this kind of guru advice, or you can listen to your heart and your community and your people and get a sense of who they are and what they need. And if you build that and deliver it, they'll buy it and you'll be rich. Um, that's and that is how we built everything in Freelance Writers Done. Was we're thinking about six different course ideas we got, which is the one you like? Oh, okay, we'll build that one. You know, just if you if you aren't don't have that sort of service leadership mentality where it's not about what you and what you think they should have and stuff, and you're not like living in your head, building things in a vacuum, and you want to get out there and get get your hands dirty and really find out what people want and build it for them, that's the community model to me, is fair enough. SPEAKER_00: Fair enough. SPEAKER_01: You are serving the community. SPEAKER_00: I'm with you on that completely. I gotta I gotta follow a question that I think I should have included that, but I didn't do that. All right. So when when when the coaches normally doing one-on-ones, how in your assessment, and if you don't know how to answer this, you can do your best, but it's totally fine. How do they replace that? You know, one-on-one mean you mean you in the coach. You're my client, Carol. One-on-one concentration on Zoom, Google Meet, whatever it is, and we're talking about things that are germane to you, things that you need help with. How do we replace that in a paid community model where I guess the the the doors are open and the curtains are everybody can see? SPEAKER_01: Well, you don't have to. I did have a few people who wanted to still one-on-one coach with me, and so I put together a coaching package for them and said, Okay, well, if you want that, you know, we can do that too. But the the key there was they asked for it, you know. And I felt that out with them, and it came from them, you know, not I'm gonna charge you ten thousand dollars because I would I need a ten thousand dollar offer and I need to make a lot of money. I think that'll make me rich, you know. If it comes from the groundswell of your community, then it's gonna be successful for you. And there's plenty of people selling high-ticket offers inside of community models. SPEAKER_00: Sure. SPEAKER_01: Plenty of people doing it. It just wasn't for my audience. And I don't know, I was like raised a like lower middle class kid, literally from like the wrong side of the railroad tracks in the San Fernando Valley in California. And the idea of charging someone that much didn't just that just graded on me. It didn't feel like me, you know. That just Wasn't where I wanted to go. I wanted it to be affordable and be for a lot of people, you know. SPEAKER_00: I love that. I love that. Thank you. All right. This part of our show is the last question of the show before we close our broadcast out. It's called a mirror check question. So time where you speak to the people who are watching and listening, either live or on replay. They spend years building somebody else's dream. And now they're faced with having to start over at a later date, having to rebuild, reinvent themselves the way that you did, Carol. What would you want to say to somebody who's in that category who knows they got to build something of their own, but they have all these barriers in their mind? My age, the time I spent, how much has been wasted. Do I have the finances? Do I have the resources? Do I have the skills? Am I enough to do this at this state? What are you saying to them, Carol? Speak to them. SPEAKER_01: You can, you can, you can. Start experimenting now. It is this is a series of science experiments. Don't feel rejected. Don't feel if the first thing you try doesn't work out and stuff. And I actually may be about to blow up a thing I'm doing and do a different thing. Like after a year and a half of doing one thing, and which I've actually never done. Like the first thing I did, it just went. But just understand that you know you have something to offer this world, and your journey is to find out what that is. Where do you fit into the marketplace? Just get on the journey. Start asking questions. What kind of audience is coalescing around you when you post about what you're interested in building? Start talking to them and asking what they want from you. If you get out of your head and ask what people want from you based on what you know, what your life experience is, you'll find a thing that you can sell to them that'll be something from your heart and that they like. And you're not too young, you are not too old, you don't know too little, you don't, you know, just all of this. There's so much of this out there. I once had a freelance writer tell me she was gonna go study at the culinary school in France, you know, at like Le Cordon Bleu, so she could write about food. And I was like, oh my God, you don't need to do that. What are you? I just don't know enough yet. You know, knowing is a bottomless pit. There is a whole lot of people out there earning good money, learning along with their people, having people follow their journey to doing something. Go check out all the reels of people who used to weigh 600 pounds and now they weigh 400 pounds, and they still have a long way to go, and they are making a fortune being honest and real with people about their journey and how hard it is. You know, something you in your life experience or your work experience in your passions and your world connects to money in the marketplace somewhere, and that's what we work on in the free week in 90 minute in 90-day community relaunch is identifying what that is. That's exactly what we do, and then you have a thing you can work on launching. SPEAKER_00: I love it. You answered my question, and your link is on the screen for you guys that are watching. If you're listening to us and you haven't gotten to replay yet, it's in the show notes and in the comment section. You won't be able to miss it. So, Carol, thank you again. She's a pioneer extraordinaire, Carol Tice. Thank you again for being a part of the show today. I really appreciate it. SPEAKER_01: My pleasure. I I prefer pioneer to what I usually say, which is dinosaur. SPEAKER_00: You're not that whatsoever. Of course, you guys are interested in what Carol is doing with the 90-day community relaunch. Of course, that link is in the show notes and in the comments section. You can't, you honestly can't miss it. You can be able to join her school and get chatted into her as a coach and as a leader. She has many insights to give to you. So the episode resonates with you at all. Reach out to her. Of course, subscribe to the Call Me Mr. You the podcast on our YouTube channel. You can always use help there or wherever you get your podcast from. Happy to continue the conversation. And don't forget, the difference between where you are or who you are and who you could be begins with what you do every single day. That's Carol Tites, pioneer, extraordinaire. I'm Mr. You. This is the Call Me Mr. You the podcast. Thanks again for being a part of this journey. We're out of the world.

Keep listening

More from the show

Image
Title