They Call Me Mista Yu
← All episodes

They Call Me Mista Yu - What Adversity Teaches Us About Identity - Patrick O'Donnell

20:11

Have a question or thought for Mista Yu? Text or leave a voicemail for the show and he’ll answer it personally on the Inspiration Station or They Call Me Mista Yu. With your Permission, We'll even play your message live on the air!

What happens when your career requires you to make life-or-death decisions—and then one day, you have to reinvent yourself?

Retired Milwaukee Police Sergeant Patrick O'Donnell joins Mista Yu to discuss leadership, courage, resilience, the emotional realities of law enforcement, and his transition from policing to bestselling author, podcast host, and entrepreneur.

Together, they explore what pressure reveals about character, how purpose evolves over time, and why your greatest impact may come after your first career ends.

Whether you're in public service, business, or simply navigating your own next chapter, this conversation offers practical wisdom on leadership, resilience, and legacy.

Support the show

In this episode

Read the transcript
SPEAKER_01: Pressure has a way of revealing who we really are. Some people experience pressure in a boardroom, others experience it when their lives are on the line. Today's guest spent 25 years making split-second decisions as a Milwaukee police sergeant, but historian life today asked the question who am I when the title is gone? Best-selling author, podcast host, and mentor, Patrick O'Donnell. Welcome to the show. Patrick, good to see you, man. Thanks for joining us today. SPEAKER_00: Thank you for having me. It's a pleasure. SPEAKER_01: See you here, brother. So let's get into it, man. So you have 25 years on the streets that teach lessons that the boardroom and the classroom cannot teach. SPEAKER_00: Yeah, you were right about that. SPEAKER_01: What's the biggest misconception people have about what it means to have courage, man? SPEAKER_00: What would you say to that? About people having encouragement? SPEAKER_01: People having courage. SPEAKER_00: Oh, courage. Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. You know, and courage comes in different ways, and you never know until you're tested. Yeah, you know, it's amazing to me how when you're a police officer in an urban environment that's heavily congested, high crime, you know, etc. etc. at night, people are shooting guns off. And you really see somebody's metal when they're actually running towards the gunfire, trying to help people that they've never met before. They have no idea who these people are, but they're running into, like, say a tavern, or I have also seen cops run into fires, like literally, before the fire department got there, I've done it twice. And you know, you're going in there to save people you've never met, you know. And you know, it's like, and you know, you've got a family too, and you've got a life, but you know, you'd raise your right hand, you took an oath, and that courage, you know, you see it, I would see it all the time, but I would also see sometimes people that you wouldn't think wouldn't be like that would kind of shy away, and then there's other people that you're like, Wow, that kind of surprised me, but I'm pleasantly surprised that you know this person really showed their stuff. SPEAKER_01: When you're in a situation where there isn't enough time to think through and over-analyze or overanalyze the situation, is there a person that you use to help you make good decisions and you think I helped the audience today? SPEAKER_00: You know, you rely on training and experience. Okay, and if you don't have a lot of training, like you say you're a rookie, you know, you don't know a whole lot, a lot of it just comes from how you were raised, you know, how mom and dad taught you when you were little, you know, golden rule treat others as you wanted to be treated, just doing the right thing. Yeah, I had a boss one time tell me says, You'll never go wrong doing the right thing, and he was 100% correct on that. SPEAKER_01: I love that, man. One of the things we talk about, a lot of this on our men's uh our men's podcast, but we talked about a lot on this show as well. The uh topics surrounding identity, around profession, around uh narratives that people say we should be following. What was for you, Patrick, the hardest part of laying the badge down and kind of discovering who Patrick is without the uniform? SPEAKER_00: Well, I'm a big fan of the saying, and I wish I made it up, but I did not, but I use it all the time was dig the well before you're thirsty. I love that the great part about being in public service is most of the time we know when we're gonna pull the pin, we know when we're eligible to retire. And I'll tell you what, it being street cop for 25 years, that's a young guy's game, that's not an old guy's game. I was 55 when I pulled the pin. That was old, you know. That's it take your body takes a beating, so you have to take a step back and say, you know what, this is not forever. And this, I mean, this is a huge part of me, but it's not me, you know. If you if you feel what I'm saying, you know, it's you have to find out who you are, you have to be comfortable in your own skin, and you have to be able to, like you said, lay that badge on the table and your gun and all of your equipment. And it's like, okay, I'm no longer Sergeant O'Donnell, I'm I'm just John Q citizen. And for me, it was a gigantic relief. I remember walking out after I turned all my stuff in the day I retired. I'm like, I don't have to make life and death decisions anymore. Not like on a daily basis, because I was a boss, I was on the street, I supervise the cops that were on the street. So I'm the ones like, okay, should I call the SWAT team? Should do we have enough to kick kick that door? Do we have enough to arrest that person? You know, it's like, ah, do I need more cops? And if I don't call enough cops and something bad happens, that's that falls squarely on my shoulders. But you don't want to be chicken little, you know, the sky is falling every five seconds. Oh, absolutely, absolutely. You know, so you have to find that, you know, in between. So walking out that door, again, I'm just like, I have to, I'm responsible for me and my family. And of course, if there's a stranger and I can help, I'm gonna help them. But I don't have that magnitude, I don't have political pressure on my shoulders, I don't have to worry about being on the evening news that night. You know, I all that has happened to me, and all of a sudden, in one stroke of a pen, it was all gone. SPEAKER_01: I know that especially today in in this era that we're in, law enforcement officers officers are kind of a lot of them are taking it on the chin. You've seen humanity at its best and at its worst in your job. How did you go about protecting your heart, man? Because I know that there's people who kind of just expect people who have influence, who have authority, get to kind of just be automatized and just not feel stuff and just get the job done and and make things work out for them. But how did you protect your heart, man, and not become emotionally numb? Well, if you did get numb, how'd you get unnumbed, if you will? SPEAKER_00: Yeah, you will become numb. There is no doubt about it. Wow, but there's a there's a time and a place, yeah. When you're in the middle of say the call for a dead infant, which unfortunately I've had a bunch of those, and you don't know if it's a homicide, you don't know if it's a natural death, you don't know, you don't know when you walk in unless it's like very obvious, which I've had those two, unfortunately. And you treat it like a homicide, and you have to be stoic, you have just do your job, you know, and you have to preserve the scene, and there's all kinds of exterior things, you know, there's gonna be family running up to the door, they want to, you know, comfort, you know, mom. There's there's all kinds of stuff going on that's very emotional, and you have to literally detach yourself from all of that. And you go home, and there's healthy and unhealthy ways of dealing with it. The unhealthy way, and I've seen this more than one time, is you know, the answers aren't at the bottom of a whiskey bottle. Booze, drugs, you know, any kind of addicting, you know, behavior like gambling, whatever the you know, fill in the blank. There's healthy and unhealthy. I'm a gym rat. I always have been. You know, my way of coping with things was a, I love to go work out, so I just I worked out every day, and I still do, you know, it becomes a habit. So try to live a healthy lifestyle. And the second thing was unfortunately, a lot of cops fall into this trap of their only friends on planet earth are other cops, they think they're the only ones that can understand them, and for certain situations, they are the only ones that will understand you know what they have gone through or whatever, but you can't live in an echo chamber, and I think that that's one of the biggest problems with our society today. Everybody's picked a side, everybody's picked a group, and they're unwilling to hear other people's narratives, they're unwilling to hear other people's point of views, and that's a very dangerous thing. So I told my rookies, I said, Whatever friends you had before you got on this job, hold on to them for dear life because you're gonna need them later. And no truer words of said because somebody told me that, and I I repeated that ad nauseum for you know the guys that I worked with, and I'm like, you know what? Just hold on to the your friends that are not cops, you know, you'll get through it. You know, there's no atheists in foxholes, you know, everybody has a different degree of faith, and when you go through extreme things, it seems like it goes extreme in either direction. Either you're more or less cursing God, you know, for how could this have happened? Then there's the other side is like, well, thank you, God. I I actually got out of X, Y, or Z last night, and I didn't think I was going to. I've had that happen to me more than one time. You're like, there is no way I should be standing and breathing right now. Or you know, you go to the shooting and this guy is shot eight or nine times, and he's walking out of the ER like three hours later. It's like, how could this happen? You know, I've seen things with my own eyes. You're just like, so it will test you spiritually, it'll test it'll test your muster, but you just gotta keep pushing forward. It's like anything else, you know, it's like say you injure your knee, your shoulder, your whatever, you know, you get fixed up, but you got to keep moving. One of the biggest mistakes people make, especially when they get older, they stop moving. And you can never ever stop moving, you got to keep pushing forward. It's really important. SPEAKER_01: I know that generally speaking, a lot of folks find a benefit to have a cop as a friend. When you're in a situation where you see all that's going on with law enforcement throughout the country, I'm pretty sure that somebody who's your friend wants to get your take on it. Wants to know if you have inside information or uh insight into that situation. How do you deal with that with not so much when I crossing the line, but it's just helping them understand, you know, that you don't have to answer those questions, and all you can share is your perspective, and we've seen what they see. How do you not speak for law enforcement across the border, but kind of help the person who's asking you for all this information and insight, if that makes sense? SPEAKER_00: That makes sense. It makes total sense to me. You know, I was the incident commander for seven officer-involved shootings where a police officer had to shoot and kill somebody. And I the last two, I was a block away when it happened. So this is what I tell people. Most of these circumstances happen very, very fast. You know, yeah, you could have like a barricaded situation with like a SWAT setup, like you see on TV, you know, where there's hours of negotiation, and you know, like say somebody's trying to rob a bank and you know they take hostages, and you know, you've seen this portrayed on TV a zillion times, you know, that kind of thing. The reality is most officer-involved shootings happen in two or three seconds. You know, it there's some kind of confrontation, there's some kind of contact, and before you know it, bull bullets are whizzing around. You know, that's that's reality. That that's what actually happens. And it's traumatic for everyone. I'll never how can I put this the right way? You know, I'll never lessen, no matter what kind of criminal history the person that the officer you know had to shoot or kill or whatever, their life. You know, they have they have made maybe they made some really poor choices, maybe they put themselves in this position, maybe they have a lengthy criminal history. You know, who knows? Whatever. But they still have a mom, they still have a dad, they still have a brother, they still have a sister. Somebody is gonna be grieving because they're gone, and we can't lose sight of that. And transversely, that police officer will be affected the rest of their life. They didn't wake up that morning and say, you know what? Boy, I hope I get into this officer-involved shooting where my face is gonna be plastered all over social media, the news, my kids, their little uh buddies in school are gonna be like, How come your dad killed that guy? Boy, your dad's a monster, your dad is this, your dad is that. Then you know, his wife is at work, and it's like, all the little whispering and little hushing, you know, blah blah blah. Oh, yeah, she's the one her husband did, you know, X, Y, and Z. It runs deep, it really does, but it is a fact of life, and you know, I tell people it's like trust the process, you know. There these get investigated for almost a year, sometimes more. I mean, they they pick it to pieces. There's nothing hasty about it, and what really gets my goat is politicians or other community leaders or whoever that jump to conclusions like one or two hours after the situation, before all the facts have been produced, before there's an investigation for their own, you know, means to get ahead and whatever. And all that does is it just causes confusion and it causes really hard feelings on both sides. You know, it's it doesn't do anybody any good. What I tell people, hey Pat, what do you think about you know X, Y, or Z? We just had a shooting in Madison actually, uh, yesterday, where police officer shot and killed a guy with a knife. And if anybody asks me, right now, I'm sorry, what it's on my screen right now, yeah. Yeah, yeah. And my advice to anyone is let the investigation run through, and then the chips will fall where they may. It's really that simple. I mean, yes, it's very emotional, you know. Unfortunately, the cops didn't have body cameras. I I don't know why. A liber as liberal as that town is, I lived there for six years. You know, I would think that they would. I'm kind of shocked that they don't make sense, but yeah. I mean, I but the problem with a cell phone video that's like 75 yards away is you're not seeing exactly what's happening. And I've had situations personally where somebody had a cell phone and they're taking video, and from that one angle, it looks like A is happening when actually C, B, D, E were actually happening. Camera angles can be very deceiving, and again, get know all the facts before you start condemning or agreeing with whoever. You know, I'm gonna be neutral until you know the investigation's done. It's like okay, let that investigation play out, then uh then we'll go from there. SPEAKER_01: Okay, makes sense, man. That makes sense. That's that's fair. Last two questions, and then we'll go ahead and close the broadcast out. So you're doing something that I talk to a lot of people about on this show specifically, where you've had a long time career, your identity was wrapped up in the thing that you did, whatever that was. Now you transitioned into something different. In your case, it's entrepreneurship and being a best-selling author. What kind of advice do you give to the listener today who's watching live on replay, who's starting an entirely, completely new chapter, and perhaps have some feelings and concerns and reservations. What would you say to the pet? SPEAKER_00: Well, the ideal way to do it, I think, is again dig that well before you're thirsty. You may not like being a writer, you may not like being a podcaster. I mean, you know what it's like, it's a lot of work, you know. It feels like it never ends, you know. So, my advice to you is dip your toes in that water before you retire, before you resign, before you walk away from whatever. Make sure this is something that you're gonna enjoy doing. Secondly, give yourself some grace. You know what? Yeah, I want to be a writer. You start doing it before you leave, things are going good. Then before you know it, hey, you know, nothing is you feel like nothing's going right. It's like, oh man, I just don't have it today, or whatever. Don't beat yourself up so badly. It's not the end of the world. There's nothing wrong with changing a little bit or pivoting. I guess that's what the cool kids say is pivoting. Yeah, yeah. I'm into the program, I'm not a kid at all, so I need to do it. But you know what? You know, be flexible, give yourself some grace, and just enjoy it. And you know, here's my advice to anybody that's done what I have done. Don't you know retire on Friday and expect to start a whole new career on Monday and be at the same level that you were for 25 years. Yeah, it took 25 years for you to achieve that level of professionalism, of you know, competency, etc. If you say you go into a totally different kind of business, not even entrepreneurial, you go work for ABC or whatever, you're probably not gonna step in there the first day and know everything about everyone, know everything about the job and be a superstar. You know, it's like it's humbling, you know. But expect that and just enjoy the ride. You earned it. SPEAKER_01: Good stuff, man. Years from now, what would you want people to remember about you most? Not about your career, but about your character. What do you want them to remember the most? SPEAKER_00: My character. Sometimes I am called a character. Yeah, you know, I I like to think I have a sense of humor, and I like to think of that guy was of service. There's no greater thing in life than to be of service to others. I know that sounds corny, but the rewards are immense. If you are of service to others, either you're a cop, you're a firefighter, you're a nurse, you're a doctor, or whatever. And you don't even have to be a first responder. You know, just I I interviewed Jack Carr on my podcast, and I asked him, I said, if you had a billboard, what would you put on there that millions of people could see? And he said, never miss an opportunity to make somebody stay. And I'm like, man, if I could be remembered for that, that'd be awesome. SPEAKER_01: That's a good one. SPEAKER_00: I like it, man. SPEAKER_01: Thanks for being a part of this conversation for sharing your story, man. Profound insights from the other side of law enforcement. Thank you for sharing your story, man. Appreciate it so much. Thanks for having me on. It was a pleasure. If this episode and Patrick's story resonates with you, of course, don't let the conversation stop here. Continue to follow his journey. You can connect with him at copsandwriters.com. The link to the website is in the show notes. Also in the comment section where you can find it. If you're listening, you're not watching, you can find it there very easily, copsandwriters.com. Along with that, please keep following the Callby Mr. You the podcast and for more conversations just like this one. Thanks again for being a part of the conversation. It's been great. Patrick, thank you again, sir, for being part of this. And we'll see you guys on the other side.

Keep listening

More from the show

Image
Title